What would you say when someone tells you "Have you gained weight?" in front of others?
It was full of people and I would not say the comment was really welcome. Yes, I did gain weight, I have to admit, not that much... She did not mean to insult, but I would not consider it to be a compliment either.
How about "no, I just got fluffier".....I'm sure the person wouldn't know what to say after that!! lol
hahaha... That guy wont say it again after this answer even if you get 90kg more... Good answer indeed...
I would be upset as that is one of the worst question to be asked in front of others as it is insulting and hurtful . I find it hard to come up with a quick answer so end up just going quiet . I would feel like asking if they had taken a NASTY pill that morning .
How about "No, have you". This will force them into the position they tried to place YOU in and will let them know how ignorant they really are for asking such a rude question!
Honestly, I would care if someone told me that I gain weight because I am 124 pounds. After Christmas and Thanksgiving holiday I may weight 145 pounds and I do not mind if someone says you gain weight because it looks so girly looking, if you keep in shape. I may feel hurt if I weighted over 350 pounds.
Lucky you to be so thin and comfortable with your figure; however, I think the questioner - like most women - is weight sensitive.
Thank you and I noticed that guys are attracted to women with large body parts. It does not bother me because I not interested in their wild desires. So that may be why I do not get insulted when someone try to be malicious..
It depends on the circumstances. Within my family or close friend circle I'd feel free to be sarcastic and come back with something snarky like, "Yes, and thanks for bringing that to everyone's attention".
In in a social setting, the office, or in public, I'd probably stick with a flat (but polite) "no", which should pretty much end any discussion.
If the questioner is crass enough to continue commenting (or, if anyone else does), I'd probably go with something like, "Oh, talking about me is so boring, what we really want to know is about your (son, job, vacation, fill in the blank), Sheila." Deflecting can work well with rude people.
And yes, unless you've desperately been trying to gain weight, the weight question was rude.
As Claudia said, circumstances might determine the reply. But my weight is so stable, ranging between 117-122, that it would be an unlikely question which would proclaim its own absurdity. Such a question would be rude in any and all cases, though. There are heavy people in my family and it's not up for discussion.
But perhaps offering my opthamologist's card, in such an event, would close discussion. Better still, replying, "Oh, I'm sorry, - have you been on the sauce again?" would end it.
I have to tell you a little story about something like this. I was at a surgery center waiting to go in for a minor surgery and the anesthesiologist came in to meet and talk with me. It was one of those multiple bed places with curtains between the beds. And yes, I am very overweight.
I asked him a couple of questions and he mentioned my weight--the number--in full voice, no private tone in his voice. And I called him on it (which is not really like me),I said, "yes, and now everyone else in here knows it too." And I pointed to the curtains on either side of me.
Seriously, he blanched white. With all the new privacy regs, he was really out of line.
I have to say I enjoyed his discomfort!
And of course if someone asked me about my weight in public, in front of other people, I would be very uncomfortable. I think a previous answer is a good one, to say, "No, I haven't, have you?" It puts it right back on the asker.
You could respond with, "Why Thank you! I was about to say," You too have gained a few wrinkles and at least 10 lbs. Then whisper, Perhaps we should keeps our thoughts to ourselves." Then changed the subject.
I'd try to just look at this question in a detached manner for a moment, and answer it honestly. After all, though the initial response is one of defensiveness, it does draw attention to the fact that you've let yourself go. This can be a positive reminder.
When the wind blows, some people build walls; others build windmills.
Let me try: "Thank you for bringing my attention and everybody else's that the gain is noticeable by now. I let myself go. But, honestly, I am so sick now that I have to let it be for the moment. I'll gain some more, but I'll stay positive. And fat"
I kind of agree with you. It is a rude thing to say in front of others however we can shut down and get hostile or we can look at it as a wakeup call. Sometimes that little shove can get us making better choices. It isn't right, but make lemonade.
Not cool! I would say to them: "Gee thanks, but you seem to have lost it."
"Oh, how embarrassing, I was hoping you wouldn't notice....however you are such an inspiration to me that I just wanted to be more like you. Both physically and also with regard to social skills, and with that thought in mind, I can see you still struggle..."
Yea I have gained weight but why did you loose it any worry?
Although I know stooping to her level is not the proper thing to do, I would still probably come back with, "Well yes I have and am in awe that you pay that much attention to my physical attributes to notice. Thank you," Totally inappropriate, but may save someone else from the embarrassment.
People who need to point out what someone else may consider a flaw in others, are just taking the focus off of themselves to keep from revealing there own issues, and lack of self worth.
Being a guy I would say yes that's true. Normally I would add "I'm wearing my winter coat" or "I've been living the good life too much".
Most likely it would be a friend or family member that would make a comment about weight. In many instances there is always something to crack back on them. Either way I would not let a weight comment ruin my day. Most people's weight fluctuates. There are more important things to be concerned about.
I thought I was cool enough by saying: "Yes, I have. And now I have this delicious curvy figure!" But everybody else was so tense about it - that it was palpable. These people were strangers, so it is hard to know what is best answer and when...
I cannot begin to tell you how sick and tired I am of hearing people upon seeing me for the first time in months comment on my weight instead of how good it is to see me after so long.
"Oh you've gained weight again! Why?" And of course the people who react like this are shallow ignorant losers. The woman who said that to me is an undeducated moron who cares only about how clean her house is. She went on to say: "You looked so good before." so I replied, "Well, I didn't like the way I looked. Not at all! I didn't like looking like you."
I would say "yes, I think I did. I gained the same amount of weight that your mouth seems to have since it's so big."
How rude, well just say ''why yes thank you for noticing, I have been on a weight gain diet for 3 weeks now, and have only gained a little, But your weight gain plan looks like its really working on you, mind sharing your secret ? ''
Jeez...I was about to ask if you were pregnant?! Funny how we both thought of our weight just now, right?
You should say "yes" for the affirmative and "no" if not so.
HMM I guess I would say, oh I was about to tell you the same thing. I usually am quick to put people on the soot and in their place.
by Dawn Michael 7 years ago
Unless someone has ever struggled with weight issues, I think they would have a tough time fully understanding how much of a struggle it can be for someone. I have struggled with weight issues all of my life.I can see where weight can become an issue, but I think it's important to look beyond the...
by supergood 6 years ago
Hi everybody,So did you gain weight or lost some of it in this year? Are you planing to gain or to lose it even more in the next year?
by Jacqui 5 years ago
Why ask a controversial question of others whom you do not agree with?I'd like to know what the point of this is? Do you want to learn, cause arguments or claim persecution? There have been quite a few from a number of people, like this. I'm confused, particularly due to the responses of the...
by John Hansen 24 months ago
Why are there so many questions here concerning Christian(or belief in God) vs Atheism?Is this the best platform for discussing these issues and are people really interested in the answers, or is religion vs non-religion just a controversial topic that will attract lots of debate and generate money...
by S K G Rao. 7 years ago
How many question you answer honestly in a day.I answer only one.
by cooldad 18 months ago
What if this happened today. All the news networks, all the world leaders, all the scientists, all the leaders of churches announced that it was proven that God does not exist. Proven beyond any reasonable doubt whatsoever.What would you do? How would society and the world react?
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|