Editbot, which was completely unwelcome to my hubs (although who cares) decided to *edit my follower's COMMENTS!!* = "i have never heard of this before. its a (*it's a) very scary thing." You are now editing my follower's COMMENTS? You have GOt to be kidding me!!!!!!! At what point is HubPages becoming a mind unto itself? When do I get a say in how this works (or doesn't work?) on my own pages? Editing my comments is ridiculous.......
I have to agree that editing comments to a hub is ridiculous! There are apparently some editors at HP that don't have enough real work to do. Editing comments for grammatical errors reduces the spontaneity of readers' responses (and may piss some of them off so much that they stop making comments entirely). Does anyone in HP Administration ever think through the potential results of these changes-merely-for-the-sake-of-making-changes before rolling them out?
I assume that Google does not discriminate between text in your article and text in your comments. Therefore, your articles' rankings in Google search would suffer and that is what HP is trying to address. It's a change, for sure, but hardly a waste of time.
It is a waste of time because if commenters think we are changing their words they will lose faith in this site completely. You never ever change commenters words. Accept or delete, never edit.
I agree. If someone reads a hub and wants to comment, what he or she writes should be left "as is."
Absolutely agree - I always delete comments with poor spelling - but I'm not going to delete a comment for one typo!
Why do you need to delete comments with a typo? Surely that's the point, the Editbot has corrected the typo for you. Or are these typos which the Editbot has missed?
There are several things that bother some of us about editbot changing comments. Let me explain a few of them and also a few reasons they would prompt hubbers to delete the comments causing the problems.
1. Editing the words of other people without their permission feels a bit unethical. There's no warning to those who comment letting them know their words might be changed. This may make people arriving via search engine fear their words can be twisted by hub authors if they see changes they did not make on their comments. Some writers would prefer to delete a comment rather than change a person's words without permission.
2. Editbot doesn't get enough of the errors for the edits to be meaningful. It leaves the most abysmal errors alone right next to minor problems it corrects or even incorrectly corrects. The benefit isn't worth the cost in trust if the comment is changed but still isn't even close to grammatically correct.
3. Online writers have been conditioned to think that flags on working dashboards indicate something they need to address which will result in some kind of penalty if not addressed. The bots that never go away may bother people used to working inside that framework for the last decade. I think the thought behind deleting those comments is that the error flags, the robots, may eventually leave the dashboard if the comments causing them are deleted.
4. The question of whether or not hubscore is affected by the number of editbot corrections on a hub's comments hasn't been addressed clearly and decisively enough for hubbers to know for sure whether or not these cute little flags hurt their hubscores and hubber scores. Again, I think many are considering removing the comments that set off the bots to preserve their scores in case they do affect them and in case the bots ever disappear after the comments are deleted.
KyLyssa - In addition to the ethics of whether or not readers' comments should be arbitrarily edited, if HP editors attempt to edit anything--either a hub or readers' comments--and don't do it accurately, I fail to see how that could please Google!
No the point I'm making is I don't think ANYBODY (me or Editbot) needs rto delete or edit a comment for one typo.
If everything written on the net were to be perfect it wouldn't be real! We want real people commenting on hubs and real people make typos - including me.
Now if HubPages was to provide people who comment with five minutes to edit their typos that would be a really good move!
Same here. Not a single edit to the hub itself, but 9 edits on comments that are 2-3 years old. One edit was incorrect, and I haven't a clue how to uncorrect it.
While looking at the edits on my sites there is a check box next to the words that were updated. I believe that if you uncheck that box it will return the edits back to how you had them.
Just to make sure I clicked on the Editbot at the bottom of my lenses and got the following pop up.
Editbot made spelling and grammatical corrections to this Hub! To view and/or undo the edits, open the live version of your Hub and click on the grey 'show up to x corrections' button in the author center box at the top of the page.
If HP editors leave something to be desired in accuracy, they may be engaging in "busy work" trying to justify their existence.
Marina just posted an update related to EditBot here.
Another example from My COMMENTS section: "The original is breathtaking and you can spend a hour viewing it" (*an hour viewing it.) This is absolutely Ridiculous!!! !! !!
Another example from my Comments!! "very nice job learned alot, thank you!!!" (*a lot) Why are you correcting my comments!!? You have got to be kidding..
Yet another example from my Comments .. "to protect oneself" (*one self) ......
Another example from my Comments: " from San Fransisco" (*San Francisco)
Another comment corrected: "A very well written article I think its a great read" (*it's a)
" I new both, but I just didn't think of them before as being a powerful tool" (*knew)
"I try and avoid using a colon, because I'm never quite sure of how it should be used, so this was very helpful to me (as are your other Hubs) Maybe now I'll be brave enought to use a colon every now and again." (*try to; *enough) .. more Comments!
"During the mating season (spring time), he turns a bit aggressive " (*springtime)
I think I have more hubs that have corrected comments than I do those that don't.
I don't care if it's in the comments as long as it'll help with Google rankings in the long run. People need to calm down, I've seen way too much complaining when the HP staff is obviously trying to improve Hubpages and where it stands.
It so important to correct "Whats" to "What's" in a three year old comment on a successful hub!
One should ask the New York Times if it's important and if they launch their in-house EditBot to correct readers' comments.
Frankly this editor for comment is beyond silly. Makes me think to Squidoo that wasted time with such ridiculous things instead of important ones - traffic recovery - and ended up drowned.
Besides, I'm convinced that won't help anyway. Google doesn't mind proper comments - otherwise all sites would edit them; they want spontaneous comments.
I don't understand what the moaners want.
You have to remember that the notice below your profile image says: "More by this Author". Most of the above mentioned corrections are genuine, exactly as the text should have been written in the first place by people who dare call themselves "authors". Authors don't make stupid, uneducated mistakes like "whats", "than" instead of "then" etc.
Now Editbot comes along to help you learn proper English, and you get angry!
As for the comments, isn'it nice for the public to enjoy comments uncluttered with primitive errors? It may even slightly raise the average reading age, currently, that of a 12 year-old!
Editbot is your friend. With a few tweaks suggested by proper authors on all related threads, Editbot is a godsend for HubPages.
Not in the comments. People who comment do genuine comments and don't want their comments to be corrected; for whatever reason.
Plus the only way for HubPages to recover traffic is NOT with the implementation of EditBots or other fancy software.
It is in getting an SSL certification (required from Google since the beginning of this year!!!), a way to keep site scrapers off from stealing our work*, the removal of spam and other of such things. These are far more important than those small and silly edits - on my Hubs edits were definitely beyond ridiculous. "a or an" - "try and - try to" - "1960's or 1960s" and the like. Even the most glorious newspapers do have such mistakes on ALL their pages and still keep their ranking in search engines.
Whether you agree or not, traffic won't recover with this new "tool". It's nice to see your English mistakes getting a few corrections, yet this won't help the site recover traffic, thus increase advertisement rates and thus more readers and earnings for everyone on here.
*Re site scrapers: a couple of years ago I stopped reporting any of my stolen Hubs, it's useless, there were too many of them, a huge waste of time - unpaid waste of time. Strangely this site is one of the most copied sites online; it is not for no reason and the team should rather work on that instead of minimal spelling corrections.
I enthusiastically agree with you! HP should get the SSL certificate! I've already registered my displeasure with EditBot "correcting" readers' spontaneous comments about hubs, so there's no need to repeat it. However, while I'm complaining (and I am), I may as well say that I cannot understand why HP Admin. changed the opening page format from one that was inviting to readers to that cramped little vertical line of boxes with a few words going down the left side of the screen. There is nothing inviting in the "new" look. That's why I contend that HP Admin. just makes changes for the sake of making changes--not because they are improvements (as they rarely are).
I'm curious: does anyone reading on HP find the new opening format better than the previous one? If so, why?
Well the former one was the one that would feature the Hub of the Day, is it?
I thought it was too big with NO place left for what's to read on here. Yet, half the page with the HOTD and the half below with pinterest like clickable images and titles - one per section for example - would have been a good idea. I remember that Squidoo had once a great home page which generated a lot of clicks from passers by.
The times I find I have been thrown out of this web site and have to log in again, I always end up half-closing my eyes while clicking to get back to my account page. I loathe having things that do not interest me pushed into my face whether I want them or not. I have no interest whatsoever in reading hubs for the sake of simply reading them. If a hub comes up in a web search I perform (which hardly ever happens), that is a different matter, but I could not give a toss about hub of the day, hot hubs, related hubs and similar excrement.
The moaners would like more effort to be applied to better effect.
I like your enthusiasm. Why not post a new forum thread on SSL and your other concerns. I'm sure the team will listen and respond.
Apart from the SSL stuff I do think that others already started forums about them and that the team never came up with any kind of solution.
Given the low number of hubs left on my account, I won't invest more time on the site. If team reads forums, they'll see my posts; if they care, they'll do something.
You already have your own website so basically you've been wasting your time all this way writing on someone else's website. I'm moving to both Blogger, WordPress and Blogspot, btw. You?
Well first, I write wherever I want and it is none of your business.
But I will kindly answer that I wait to cashout before leaving. This account is, as I said earlier, a former Squidoo one. My main HP account was deleted months ago
I have already sent hubPages a request to take my account off, for that matter.
Hopefully we will meet on Blogger, WordPress, Blogspot (or whatever unknown, little known mysterious venue there is on the Internet that is to be found).
What??? I'm surprised, you don't like HP any more? Didn't you create a forum especially to bash other platforms such as Blogger, WordPress and the like? LOL.
Anyways, if you work hard, you'll make more money on those platforms, unless you find THE niche that is not over-exploited. Best of luck
That is not what you wrote a few posts above but this is none of my business so I'd day goodbye for now.
a small reminder for the really confused
What's your problem?
Not confused, but you seem to be a bit confused
Now, if you don't mind, I'd like this forum to focus on its main topic; which is related to the EditBot not to your endeavours.
Haha! DasEngel, you finally got the message. You're not quite as dumb as I thought (though I do hope you eventually work out that Blogger and Blogspot are the same thing).
I'll reply to this observant critique of yours. After 7 years, that is.
(Regarding your edit: I avoid the trap.)
After 82 minutes: How much success is it (as a personal website owner) if I own two unpopular, seldom-visited websites one of them being on sale?
I would've thought not at all successful, are you in that position?
Looks like invaded by weird-looking tv-shaped aliens. Lots of them because I have hundreds of comments in many of my hubs. Two thumbs DOWN!!!
Yep. If I have errors in my hubs, they are usually meant to be there.
I stopped paying attention to the EditBot corrections the day after it went "live." Out of my 100 or so Hubs that received the EditBot scan (so far), only ONE had a legitimate typo in the hub itself. The rest were in the comments left by others. It's not my fault that the people who comment on my Hubs can't spell!!
And on top of all that......ever since these horror bots have invaded the hubs, my daily read score has dropped right down! bah humbug!
Hubpages is really trying to help us. I just don't like how my page looks such a mess.
Today I've just gone through my hubs and checked all the corrections.
Most of them were fine, and just typos. Some of the corrections, however,
were spellings of which I use the Australian, or British spelling for words.
These changes, I just don't accept.
Also, there were a few place names which were changed, so obviously the
editbot is unable to differentiate between capitalised names, and similar words.
Yes, I know I can untick the box and refuse the alteration, but this is time-consuming.
Would also like the little symbol to be removed once I've checked the hubs, and
I think HP is looking at this.
I'm glad to have the typos corrected, but hope the bot doesn't come through my
hubs again any time soon!
by Eugene Brennan 4 years ago
I just came across this one, KaKun dot ru, complete with Adsense ads. Has anyone else seen this?
by Alianess Benny Njuguna 7 days ago
After replying to a comment, an author is given five minutes to make any changes to his/her comment. What if later on the author wants to make changes or edit his/her comments e.g. correcting gammar mistakes?Another area I would consider it useful to inclide editing feature is in Q&A. For...
by John Hollywood 3 months ago
I have a question that I hope someone from HP will answer. I have an article that has been up for about 5 years. It has been edited by HP Pro. Drives LOTS of traffic to Paired Life (as in one of your biggest articles). Who was the moderator who thought it was a good idea to turn off my advertising?...
by Steve Andrews 6 years ago
When it was first introduced I was annoyed by it but made an effort to tweak my hubs to get them out of Idle status. Now, a whole load have got zzs against them again and many of them are hubs that at one point were very successful and even now still have scores above 70 or higher.One of the hubs...
by Elizabeth 5 years ago
For several months now (almost since I joined hubpages) I have been getting harassing, threatening and ridiculous comments from the same person. I originally encountered her in a forum, and she has not left me alone since. She repeatedly leaves me harassing fan mail, none of which has...
by Ziyena Brazos 2 days ago
Has anyone removed a portion or all of their comments from each published article, and if so, do you think this has helped or hindered your Google ranking and traffic?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|