A little bird told me that HubPages are considering charging Forum Users for the amount of space that they take up when they reply to Forum posts, and quote screen after screen of someone elses comments above their own one line contributions.
This makes the forums very hard to read, as it's hard to pick out your little nugget of truth out of the screenfulls of quotes, requotes, re-requotes, and re-re-requotes of other peoples stuff.
This practice is clogging up the hub pages servers, and I have it on good authority that a fee is being considered for this waste of hub pages resources. The fee will be deducted from your HubPages earnings.
So - just in case this is true, here's how to avoid paying this fee.
When you click quote/reply on a forum post, remove all of the stuff that is not relevant to your reply. People who are following a thread don't need to keep wading through what everyone else has posted.
Use your brains. If you are making a comment about a post which appears on the same page, it's not usually necessary to quote any of the original comment.
If you're making a comment on something that appeared several pages back, usually a few sentences of the original post is sufficient.
In the interests of saving you money -
and reducing the wear and tear on PG DN keys,
Eric G. :-)
After seeing some of the threads that have been posted here in the forums lately you wonder if there is any of that left...
Eric you're positively right. Thumbs up to you for pointing it out here.
You may want to add a disclaimer or something. Certain parts of the community never evolved irony genes and may take this seriously.
Unfortunately - this is probably your target audience.
Mark, I think YOU are his target audience: http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/13547?page=4#post158816
I think that was a technical glitch. Pretty good though - I have never seen quite that many in one go - but I couldn't work out how to clean it up and still keep the quotes from the other thread:(
There is nothing more irritating than having someone reply to an uber long post.
What's worse is when someone replies to someone's reply of an uber long post. You know what I mean?
Maybe it's a good hub idea- forum etiquette at hubpages.
If I may humbly add to the list of forum no-no's, it would be to hit the enter key after every sentence or two.
This is generally how most forum posts get to be too long- too many enter keys are hit too frequently.
VERY good point, WC! I think it would make a great hub. I'm willing to write it. Might be good for me considering that I'm a culprit who writes exceptionally long forum posts in general.
I would like to add that the quoted point of yours applies to anywhere that we write, be it on a forum, in an e-mail or in one of our hubs. I have just as much trouble reading a hub that is made up of very short paragraphs as I do with reading a hub that is made up of huge blocks of text.
Thank you for the reminder!
I agree, I am glad that someone took the time to share on the proper way to post to the forums.
So is there a good rule of thumb for how many times we should quote previously replies? 10? Maybe even 20 times?
Well, I'm back from the wilderness with no internet, no mobile phone, and no TV.
And I survived!
No. Like I said in the original post - that's what your brain is for.
@Maddie - I didn't consider Mark as my target audience - but thanks to your research skills, he is now
Calm down - no need to fill your keyboard with sticky fluids.
I wasn't saying anything about the length of someone's response to a forum post - just the problems caused when a poster includes replies to a post, and includes someone ELSE'S huge responses.
Although HP can't directly take money from you, they theroretically COULD juggle the precentage of advert impressions that you receive, and indirectly charge you that way :-)
(But I'd take a guess that this wouldn't be popular.
How's THAT for understatement
Eric are you honestly serious???? Really serious??? Wouldn't that take away from HP? One would think that some hubbers would pull there accounts and quit.
About the fees - No.
About deleting the unnecessary bits? - Yes.
(See, that's how it's done. I deleted most of what AEvans said, and just left the relevant bit. It's pretty easy to do really )
Ahhh that is nifty , operation erase and delete.
Good thought. Its essential to save hubpages resources. I don't wanna see hubpages saying OUT of Bandwidth like twitter.
You do realize that HP doesn't pay us right, so there isn't an actual HubPage earnings? Google, Amazon, Ebay, and Kontera pay, so HP wouldn't be able to take money away, unless they charged and it was all out of our pocket.
So, to answer your question, no it wouldn't take from HP earnings. It would add to it.
Very Good AE!
But you didn't delete anything.
Have another try, and just leave the following words in the quote box:
"About the fees - No.
About deleting the unnecessary bits? - Yes."
A clever puzzle.
And for instance, this line is filler.
Yes Sir Dent - Exactly like that !
Well, I'll leave you all to it now.
I'm going somewhere for a couple of days where there probably isn't internet access.
Hope I survive :-)
*slaps a cable patch onto Eric* Good luck indeed.
LOL. I'm seriously considering myself as one who won't survive without it after tweeting for 3 days!
But you're not really getting the point of this whole post!
Which is to chop out the quoted bits that are not needed
Haha, I already do that (most of the time, and at least with ever increasing regularity). I'm being a rebel.
It's about time this was brought up. I was going to a few times, in fact I do believe I mentioned to a certain J.U. that great big slabs of text need not be quoted every single time. Hit post to reply generally, and if there is something specific you need to reply to so people don't lose track of the conversation, do as Mr Graudins has suggested, delete everything but the bit you're responding to.
Eric can bite and soothe at the same time. His message in this thread is fully loaded and well intended.
Thank you for that. I couldn't possibly allow them to chunk my $1 something earnings. LOL
This info you posted is actually helpful for hubpages. Thanks.
It does help bandwidth, but it also helps readers. It's confusing to see things quoted four or five posts included in the most recent post.
I also need to take into consideration what one hubber (can't remember who!) said about making it a hub if it's long enough to be one! Yikes!
Oh EG this is insane.It will never work with me I always have so much to say, I do not understand the word condensing. I know of the word Condensed Milk,mmmmmmmmm, I wish I had some right now....maybe not a real good idea my keyboard gets so sticky LMAO. See how could I have said all this to you in one sentence.This is important details I am exchanging with you
this is fictitious ,
eric , only wan't good answers , not unwanted ,
or eiter ,
he is worth trying to improve her image on hubpages.
i alredy don't post any unrelated materials.
if you were saying true.
i don't want to worry about this.
Oh Eric G you were just making this up. Ohhhhhhhhhhh. You are such a character you are you had me going.Ooooooooo. Twenty a spankings for you,over my knee you go. Would you rather I used a wooden spoon or my fly swatter. Hang on I don't have a fly swatter, my gran did.Mmmm what else can I use......will have to be a frypan
And no doubt you'd bring your usual film crew, and end up selling this on the internet, with all your other home movies. I'm awake up to you
well ive deleted ,now Im not sure how this is gonna submit ,oh be gentle with me Hub Police lol.
I think it's great NOT having all those posts squished all together,and one night I called hubby over to read one of them ,and he couldnt figure out who said what ,in fact his response was "what the hell are those people on"
Fantastic idea. Totally approve of these space saving techniques!
I know could we start a Club..... This loser sold a painting today, so I think my Art is where I will head in future. What are the Medals, I don't know if I have any, and can I wear them out in public Just joking.
Well I as another loser will happily read it. Do you feel if we brush up on self esteem, we may cease to be losers, I might hang on to that thought. Thnx for that I was soooo down.... I have a medal for doing 100 Hubs, and having 5000 views they happened ages ago..... I can't believe I missed them. Sort of like being a War Hero, I think they call them reluctant Heroes, because they lack the ablity to see that they have done something Heroic.
You have truly made my Day....!!!!!!!!!
My colleagues have sat here for the last hour reading all the Hubs, they think you are " Quite a card, (I said he is a Pirate ! so dissappointing that it may be they don't think you are a Loser, you will have to try harder. Two are professional and Jacqui is a Lawyer, I tend to take advise from successful people Funny eh.. But then I am a total loser. hahahahahaha
Sadly there some Forums, that they believed werent, worth posting. None thankfully mine, nor yours, Do you think we could be loosing the Loser touch. I am off to Work now.
Eric I can see you getting on the list ease off a bit it is a scary place to be, its accidental, but you can easily find yourself there. haha just joking.
If there's something interesting to respond to, or people to communicate with in the short time I spend here I'll do so.
I don't care about where I am on some smeggin' list
(But thanks for the warning. If I get to the top of it, do I win a pony or something ??? )
No actually I think I just hand over the Trophy I had no idea I would receive when i got on a List, I handed actually noticed. Its real ugly and a Dust collector.
I am wondering if this is the start of something. There was a story on the news about Twitter preparing to charge people. If they do I'm gone from there. I can handle the quote thing becaue I rarely do that. If charges start coming down for other operations I will be history.
Twitter is a pain full of twitterworms and viruses, I wouldn't touch it with a 10' disinfected Bargepole.
by Howard S. 7 years ago
When replying to a forum post, we are given the opportunity to "import and edit the quote." If the comment to be quoted contains an image, only the text below the image will be imported, the image and any text above it is not captured.As long as you're looking at that code anyway, it...
by Motown2Chitown 5 years ago
Some of us are encountering an issue in the forum. On the front page, it will indicate that responses have been made since we last participated in a thread, but when we click on the name of the most recent respondent, rather than being taken to that response, we come to the start of the last page...
by Om Prakash Singh 9 years ago
by Lily Rose 9 years ago
I know I can include someone's comment by clicking "reply" on their post, but how do you quote more than one person's post within your reply, or even just a portion of someone's comments (without having to copy & paste, of course)?
by Disappearinghead 5 years ago
This is a problem I encounter on Mac OS running Safari, iThings running IOS6, and Windows Phone 8. As I work my way down a thread, I can click the 'Reply' link only to a certain level. As the thread goes deeper, the 'Reply' link disappears, yet plainly there are those who are able to continue reply...
by Hugh Williamson 2 years ago
Paid forum posting is a business that's growing rapidly because of the glut of money in politics and the desire of commercial interests to promote their products and to blunt criticism.Should paid forum posters be forced to acknowledge that they are being paid? Should they be banned from posting...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|