Is anybody else irritated that when answering a question, you get told the answer is too short?
I have tried answering a few questions, and while I am not just writing yes or no, I apparently don't have enough words. I had a 6 word answer and they wouldn't accept it. Do you think that forces a better answer... or going against someone being able to just give the answer they want!
No I do not, one to four extra words to me is not a bother.
Sometimes a question only requires a short answer. I have noticed short answers posted to some questions but when I write a short answer it is rejected. Perhaps new rules are now in place and the short answers, I have seen, were posted before the new rules came into force. I do find it annoying that my "answer", which is my response to a question and therefore exactly the right length....short or long that I have chosen, is deemed "too short" by someone else.
Yes, I just joined, and I think it is the most annoying restriction of all time. How could they do this to us?
Yes...I am. I think that a person should be allowed to choose the length their answer. if it only requires two or three words...so be it! However, some questions require lengthy explanations. This would mean more words. I hate it, when a company that has to shut down operations for so-called "system-updates (see 'our stupid techs screwed up')" tell *me* how to write. According to my reading, about half of them can't even use the English language properly! They only got their jobs because they're cheap labor!
I agree. Sometimes the best answer is short and sweet. I usually put my 3 or 4 wards followed by a lot of these.........................to fill in
Yes! The rest of this answer is BS. It is only here as a means to convince HubPages that this is relevant to the question. A lot like those essay questions in school where you just wrote words to fill the space. I think this is enough. Thanks for listening and have a GREAT day!
i did until i decided to just hold down the period button for a bit. now i can answer with the word no..................................................
I have to say yes. Ran into this the other day when, literally, all I wanted to answer was yes. Couldn't do it, so then I had to think of more BS words just to fill space. From now on I'll just do this .......... Didn't think of that. Awesome!
If you are required to explain then probably you must give your best shot and if it could be only answer by some short answers like yes/ no then why you have to give a longer one?
KISS (KEEP IT SHORT AND SIMPLE)
Short answers are good. Otherwise, you have to filter through garbage and filler-yuk! No one should dictate the lenght, it's your answer.
Short answers are sometimes the right answers and should be allowed.
ammmmmmmmmmmm nop.................................i dont think so
I think they want these to by more essay-style answers... Just possibly. o.o; I usually look at it and wonder... "Did I write too much? I wonder if they'll actually read this..." because I end up writing a paragraph or two on the questions I answer. ^^;
and i'll have to put in all this blabber so my succinct, accurate, and precise answer will be allowed.
i think it illistrates how a site can claim to be "the" place for creative writers, then imediately construct a set of rules that restrict creativity,.... perhaps they think were all in training to run for political office, in which case any answer that uses the maximum amt of wods while giving no real answer gets the prize,... creative vaguery.
"too promotional" "sub standard",... what are these labels and who defines them?
hemmingway woulda got his adds jerked here, so would stienbeck, so would sinclair lewis,... but then again, non of them will be remembered for writing self help pages about how tro loose 10 lbs in 10 days while removing the stains from your best shirt and winning your clingy demanding girlfriend back....
but they will all be remembered,... unlike the authors of those litterary wonders.
was that answer long enough,.... i think it clearly demonstrates that less is often more.
all wanted to say was,.......
Yes. It is annoying when your answer is too short. Please make it longer.
I sure do; sometimes you can convey something adequately in just a few words just as well as you can in a paragraph more. And sometimes being required to give a long answer just means you have to find ways of saying the same thing over again, or at least to find different ways of phrasing it, or at least expressing it slightly different.
Or, in other words, yes.
Shoot what if the answer is just yes or no? Oh I forgot, that's a question!
I agree. I have had that as well and had to add words that didn't add anything at all to the quality or sense of my reply. But it's not just a case of me feeling a short answer is best, many people who post questions only want a short reply back. So is it annoying - yes!
I may or may not like or dislike people or answers that are vague because when all is said and done, at the end of the day and to be perfectly honest, perhaps I do or do not have the answer.
What they said.".............."......................................
I guess they want us to waste words, or maybe succinct isn't in the hubber's dictionary.
Hasn't been a problem for me yet, and probably won't now that I've read all the ways to work around it from here.
And just to be a pain, use blah blah lbah blah blah lbah blah blah blah blah after your answer to make it longer blah blah lbah lbah blah
To answer your question in more than 6 words would be like this.
Sometimes I have tu cut the answer, but, normaly, because I'm a journalist and need to be concise.
Yes, it has happened to me on a couple of occasions. Maybe that particular area should be reviewed as sometimes all we need to answer is simply 'Yes' or 'No'
I have an answer but it is too short. Sorry I guess you'll never know =[
Yes. One way to counter is that first you write an answer according to the rules set, but edit to make it shorter in the 10 min edit period. It works.
One of the other member (Manna in the Wild) also used this 'trick' in this answer.
That hasn't happened to me yet but life is to short so answer how you feel it is needed and move on.
answer given is depends on who is asking . if person we like then not irritated and if person we don't like then irritated from first question
I think it's all a conspiracy by the AMA to make us type more and in turn more people get Carpal Tunnel Syndrom and Tendonitis. It's all a scam and we should revolt.
I'm just kidding, I'm usually pretty long winded anyhow. Maybe they should put limits on how long the answers are instead.
Wisdom does not have too be lengthy. An accurate and concise answer is better than long winded nonsense.
I'll have what Peter Davis is having! (Harry Met Sally reference)! LOL!
well, if a short answer is your style, you should keep that style.
very because sometimes all the qushtion requiers is a one word answer
What is usually does it write the person question then i give my short answer to avoid that pop up. however question can be answer with the yes/no response.
The nature of someone asking a questions means that they are lacking knowledge in the area, and you the 'expert' have that knowledge. It's easy to forget how little someone might know about something. It's hard to force yourself to be so descriptive but sometimes it's necessary to go the extra mile to answer the question properly.
I don't know, but I do & they're awful. My mom had 'em & we laughed at her. Oh, brother, it's not funny. I don't think men have 'em ... I haven't seen any men with a waterfall running down their foreheads.
Yes. Some questions can be answered sufficiently with a short response.
Oh yes, this has happened to me, too. I don't like it; sometimes a short and sweet answer is sometimes a lot more apt to the question.
by DougBerry 7 years ago
So, are you just answering/asking questions to get an accolade? I am.
by Mr.NGR 7 years ago
Why do prefer answering questions to asking questions?If the other way around then why do prefer that?
by Heidi 8 years ago
What motivates you to answer questions on HubPages?
by Billie Kelpin 6 years ago
So, I understand that the question-answer section is to inspire hubs, BUT it feels a little disingenuous to use the information everyone provided, especially when that information would fit nicely in a list. I asked a question about recipes and received lots of great replies. How do I make a...
by Eric Dockett 2 years ago
What the heck is the point of Q&A? I don't mean that sarcastically. I am really trying to figure it out. I can't formulate a strategy for properly using this feature unless I can understand the intent behind it.First the Q&A questions/answers were on their own pages with their own urls. It...
by Poon Poi Ming 7 years ago
Hi, I wonder why I am suddenly banned from answering questions. Is the ban permanent or temporary? I have written to the HubPages Team but I thought that I may be able to get a faster response here. Is there a guideline on how to answer questions? Honestly, I really don't know which rule I have...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|