Really? This is supposed to be where people can talk about HP and writing, but it is full of inconsequential nonsense and spammers. Surely HP moderators, you can do something about this?
There must be a place for quotes and games on the Topical forums?
Please clean it up and move 'Freeform' over to the dark side.
Questions about HP Forms for help are "Getting Help for HubPages," "Hub Challenges," "Improving Your Article," and "HubPages Tutorial and Community." I will continue to post quotes in "Freeform Discussion." I get a lot of positive feedback. Just saying.
It's clutter, Kenna. I already suggested you use ONE thread and post your quotes in it, instead of posting a new one every single day. You will still get your feedback, don't worry, and it means the forum has fewer fluff posts to scroll though.
If it were possible to filter out Freeform, then many of us would do it. Unfortunately we can't.
Games should be in the topical forums under games & puzzles while quotes should be in books & literature, not in the freeform section.
I thought this was the whole point for making a "topical" section of the forums. So this kind of thing wouldn't happen.
One of the things I think would help is if they made the other forum topics more prominent somehow - maybe through use of tabs. I used to post on other topics like martial arts, etc. in the proper forums and no one would respond. At some point I realized that the only place to get attention was the Free Form Discussion forum. I only use it - I don't use the other forums -but I do restrict what topics I post - though I hardly ever post a topic. Funny thing is, the Free Form Discussion forum is actually for anything, including games and quotes, etc. It is the other way around in a way. People posting about traffic, rules, improving articles, really should be posting in the proper forums not the Free Form Discussion. For instance, there is a forum specifically for SEO, no one posts there. They post in Free Form Discussion on that topic.
The trouble is, they ALL appear here: https://hubpages.com/forum/hubpages There's no distinction in the main forum feed. You can't avoid them.
However, the topical forum is separated from this one, here: https://hubpages.com/forum/topical
The topical forum is pretty busy, so I don't know why people don't use it for non-writing, non-HP stuff.
I think most people don't think of clicking on that little button that takes you to the topical forums. It's not very obvious. When you go to the forum, you land on the Hubpages forum and I think the tendency is just to scan what's posted there. I think there needs to be tabs maybe; one says Hubpages and the other Topical. Something along the lines of directing people to specifics. Maybe a specific one for freeform.
Of the 30 posts I see on the first page of the forum, I count 11 that are either spam or have nothing to do with writing on HP.
It's worse than just annoying. It creates an environment where new writers feel like this is a place to goof off instead of work hard, and successful Hubbers won't take the time to help newbies because of the frustration of wading through silly quotes, word games, personal issues, jokes, thoughts about dreams, etc.
The solution is simple - move the Freeform Discussion over to the Topical forum.
Or, create another forum where adults can talk about the business of working on HubPages without all the nonsense.
It was inevitable - once HP shut down the Q&A section, the spammers and gibberish babblers were bound to start posting their nonsense in the forums instead.
Agree 100% too. I don't really mind that there is a free form forum, but I do mind if those posts are mixed with HP help posts in the daily feed.
I agree that quotes, games, and the like should be moved to the topical forum. People are entitled to their own opinion, of course, but the threads aren't silly or nonsense for everyone. I think that the request to move them should be based on their inappropriate location rather than someone's personal view of their value.
I agree and I suspect that some people who are genuinely asking for HP help are having their posts bumped down by other irrelevant stuff that has nothing to do with Hubpages.
These Freeform Discussions and Serendipitous Threads, Puzzle Games, etc. should be placed separately in another running page.
The nomenclature of "Feed" is not appropriate. It includes all rubbish.
Kind of like the daily Google/Bing/Yahoo news pages..., which is exactly what I think HP wants. Some things are of interest; some things are not. And:
https://hubpages.com/community/forum/14 … ost3983770
https://hubpages.com/community/forum/14 … ost3982828
https://hubpages.com/community/forum/14 … ost3982593
https://hubpages.com/community/forum/14 … ost3982533
are not rubbish.
People care. People have fun. People really hurt and need to speak. Until such time as Google/Bing/Yahoo change their philosophy, I suggest you let it go.
These should all be in topical forums. Not the HP forums.
We shall agree to disagree? Besides, what with us being slammed by Real World, who cares?
Yes, exactly, they should. That's why that forum exists. For chat, for off-topic discussions, ramblings, etc. This 'half' is for people looking for information and answers regarding writing at HubPages. Why mix it up? It doesn't make any sense at all.
It's interesting that the only two people here supporting the existing arrangement are the ones who create the most off-topic threads
If they moderated the forums the way they moderate hubs ad nauseam it might be worth writing something here again. Moderators instead edit hubs and two months later flag the hub for quality. I now have my own blog and write there. Over 1,000,000 pageviews last year, won the Best New Personal Finance Blog of the Year award and broke $30,000 in revenue in 2017. 2018 is up over 400% from 2017. HP has to stop playing with the work of real professionals and moderate the BS in forums.
KeithTax, I don't ever reply here, and only log in to check my earnings from articles I wrote a bazillion years ago, but wanted to say I know you! I'm in the FI Community so was funny to read this post. P.S. I also make a full time income on my blog (well, as much as many teachers anyways). There's definitely life outside of content sites.
As with everything else here, it doesn't matter what Hubbers want the forums to be. It matters what HubPages wants the forums to be.
The message HubPages is sending is that they want these forums to be a place where people goof off, not a place where people learn and exchange ideas about writing online.
It might make HubPages more fun, but it also makes it harder for people who are trying to get better at what HP actually is about, which is supposed to be writing articles on the internet.
It makes it hard to sort through the forum for real information. It makes it hard for new writers to get help. It makes it frustrating for successful writers to provide that help. It makes you feel like you shouldn't even bother.
My issue isn't with the people posting the junk in the forums. I understand people want to enjoy themselves, be social, take a break from the world, etc. Though I do struggle to understand how Paul's post about someone making $11k here in one month gets buried by people who are more interested in word games.
My issue is more with HubPages, for not allowing people who are only interested in the writing part to have their space as well. It is really hard to understand why they won't simply move the Freeform Discussion over to the topics area.
Exactly, I get frustrated when Paul doesn't pin those posts tbh. Not because it's important, but because it gets lost in the clutter. What I do these days is I come to the forums check for any new posts (visited link colour helps) by looking at the username of the person who posted. I don't read forum thread topics anymore.
I seemed to have somehow missed this thread the first time around thanks to the clutter. Important stuff gets buried quick on the HP forums.
HP has one of the worst forum policies of any site I have known from 30 years in the business. And I work full time online.
I frankly don't give a damn how many editors they hire to work on articles. PLEASE hire at least one moderator to stop some of the forum garbage that gets posted on a regular basis.
PLEASE don't wait days or weeks to act on abusive posters.
Sites with sophisticated policies will lock threads that get out of control, delete abusive posts, aggressively ban abusive posters, etc. None of that happens here.
If HP can't or won't manage forums, then get rid of them.
Back to the Google/Bing/Yahoo thing... Front page equals various and much increased traffic. Worst case scenario, writing endeavors get shunted to topics; I don't want that either. Be careful what you wish for. HP wants the traffic. Seriously, this should be left alone. To kill front page is to kill all.
Consider the nature of our species; the current forums are a major attractant. Many writers here are already borderline as to continued participation. Writing is a darn tough business, taking away the fun is invoking the tipping point.
And if getting what some here wishes, and just allowing "writing subjects"; just what are those subjects to be? Does one want HP to decide? Or does one want HP to be as is?
Speaking in generals is not a basis for argument. If anyone looks through the threads, you will see others post topics you don't like theraggededge. Generalities are just that generalities. You made your point. I got it.
You misunderstand. It's not about whether I like the topics or not. I like a little fun as much as anyone. It's simply that the important Hubpages-related stuff gets quickly buried under the lighter non-writing related threads. Some people only visit the forums occasionally and probably miss lots of threads that they'd be interested in reading.
This forum should be dedicated to those who want to learn, ask questions, ask for help, share writing resources, improve their hubs, report technical problems, find out how the earnings programs work, make suggestions, even rant a little about editors' decisions. And, of course, discuss decisions made by staff.
And it's not as if there isn't a more appropriate place for the games and quotes, is there? No-one is suggesting banning these threads, merely posting them in the right forum.
Not quite sure what you mean about being general. I thought I was pretty specific.
I'm confused. I don't see what you're seeing.
For me the quotes and games appear under the subfolder Freeform Discussion.
The tree directory to it appears to be - HubPages Tutorials and Community»HubPages, the Community»Community News»Freeform Discussion
Which seems to be the right place for them?
Whereas this post "Why is this forum full of cr*p?" appears under Technical Questions?
Am I missing something?
I agree. Too many people using it like Facebook. It gets tedious.
The ideal solution would be if we could filter out the frivolous stuff that has no relevance to HP. But maybe there are technical issues with that, or maybe HP sees it as promoting a community?
I want to read the forums for HP-related stuff.
What is cool about this link https://hubpages.com/forum/hubpages it defines each forum. It is up to HP staff to decide how to separate them accordingly. Not the writers.
Are we not allowed to make suggestions and requests any more? When did that happen?
I think most people do post in the right topical forum. The problem however (in my opinion) is that HP displays all new entries/replies from all topical forums in one combined daily feed. That daily feed being gone will solve the 'clutter' I think. Then you can choose the topical forum you're interested in and ignore the ones you're not interested in.
That's a good idea, but it doesn't really solve the problem. The feed isn't the issue. The issue is the Freeform Discussion forum. It is an ambiguous description which some people have decided means "post any ol' thing that enters your mind, even if it is self-indulgent nonsense and/or belongs in the Topical section".
It's hard to argue with that, because HubPages does nothing to stop it.
The abundance of these off-topic posts means that posts that are actually about online writing and useful to writers trying learn how to do well on HubPages get pushed down in the forum where fewer people ever see them. It doesn't matter how you set your feed. If you come to the forum itself you are barraged with these nonsense posts.
When I first started on HubPages I knew very little about online writing. I learned a lot just by reading this forum every day.
I feel sorry for anyone starting out on HubPages today.
There's a little grey button that appears for me in my feed on the right hand side when I hover over posts. It comes up with an option to "hide stories in this topic" and you can choose to hide a topic. I managed to hide freeform discussion this way earlier.
It didn't bother me that much, but it looks like we do have a choice.
I only noticed the button earlier today, not sure if it is new.
by Don Bobbitt24 months ago
OK, I may be on a RANT, but, you people who want to use HP as some kind of social game playing site, please grow up and go over to your Facebook account. Those people are used to game players. Me? You're wasting space...
by Dawn Michael7 years ago
just because they don’t agree with you? Pcunix took one of my hubs commented on it then proceeded to write his own hub on it and posted a forum on it just because he did not agree with me? Then throughout the...
by Hamshi Edward3 years ago
I'm still kind of new here but here are my bits:-My best piece of forum advice for other newbie hubbers is, if you have a question to ask, search it up on the HP search bar or on Google to see if that question has...
by Don Bobbitt6 months ago
It looks like a fourth of my feed lately is comprised of new people wanting the rest of us to tell them how to write. All day I get request after request for help on passing the Quality Assessment. I mean Really? Many...
by Susannah Birch11 months ago
I only just realised today, when trying to find a forum post I knew I'd replied to, that there are two different forum sections - and that each one has a DIFFERENT list under 'my posts'. Am I really really behind or is...
by Raye21 months ago
Whereas I'm somewhat curious to see how HubPages new experiment for helping authors get Hub feedback help works out on the Hub author end, I'm quite dreading it as a forum reader, because it's all too clear that the...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.