I've been doing a bit more hubhopping than usual the last few days, and what I'm seeing is downright scary. I would have to say that a full one-half of the hubs I've read were nothing more than stolen content -- 100% plagiarized. Most of the remaining hubs were pure garbage and/or totally unreadable. Here's a sample:
Excursus from the wonted places you would look to gain a maize tool there is a healthy industry for using maize poppers in businesses for a variety of reasons including customer retentiveness and obligation unsatisfied kids inhabited patch parents outlet for products.
What the heck is going on? Is it a full moon or something?
Full moon and at least one bottle of vodka! LOL!
I hub hop all the time, and I honestly have never noticed stolen hubs. I have seen "copied idea" hubs, and that aggravates me...especially when I know they were ideas from me. "Get your own ideas, man".
I don't flag these, as it would be impossible to prove. I do however flag the ones that have obviously stolen pics. The ones that are like the one you wrote about get flagged as "low quality". I feel bad flagging, but gee, get with the program.
think all of us who can string three words together better go hopping
That's terrible! Wow! I can't even make out what it's supposed to say with any surety. Yikes!
It is amazing what some people publish.
I'm no longer amazed at how many people don't read TOS or general guidelines before writing or posting in the forums.
I just hopped 10 more hubs, and sure enough--five of them were stolen. And yes, they were stolen, not "duplicate." I don't believe The Food Network gets their content from HubPages.
This stolen cr*p even has people commenting on them. Like this one:
Stolen from ListVerse who originally published it in 2007:
Stop the madness!
On a similar vein but slightly off-topic, I am sick to death of seeing spun and plagiarised content on page 1 of Google just because some half-wit bought a domain name using searched-for keywords.
I thought the new Google changes were supposed to clamp down on this?
off to hub hop.
Unfortunately google never took action against plagiarized content and sites. Take a look at number of sites hosting content that is copied from hubpages.
and list goes on.. (i have more than 100 autoblogs list in spreadsheet)
Even comments from yahoo answers, hubpages answers are found on these sites as part of their ranking content.
They will be coming in to play over the next few months
Okay -- so this one was just too funny and I had to share:
Flatbottom our youngest son, who is digit, is acquisition how to use the Whirley Pop Corn popper.
Do ya think someone really named their son "Flatbottom?"
I thought MY son was the only Flatbottom! So much for being original....
Even after a very long night up with a sick baby, that one got me laughing. I had to read it twice though HAHAHA!
Only if their last name happens to be 'boat!'
But seriously, this sort of 'content' embarrasses me. But I guess that's the problem with writing sites such as HubPages-anyone can publish here, and it's up to us to 'police' activities, and bring problems to the attention of the team if need be.
I did a bit of hub hopping yesterday and found two hubs that were duplicate (probably stolen) content. And there were a couple more that were just plain cr*p. Depressing.
If anyone's unsure how to establish whether a hub is duplicate content, it's very easy to check - just copy and paste the first couple of sentences of the hub into Google's search bar.
Thanks for that, I was wondering how you would be able to tell.
Actually, I usually go to the middle of the hub and grab a couple of sentences. I've found quite a few that have had a unique intro paragraph, but the rest of the hub was copied verbatim from somewhere else. I guess they do that because most people do grab the first few sentences!
As for recipes, the ingredients list is not copyrighted, but the actual prep methods are. I just grab a few sentences from there and ignore any intro the hubber may have put on it.
Edited to add: BTW, I think Habee is on a hub publishing binge, and the recipes sound GOOD! Way to go Habee!
Hub Hopping is a valuable tool for all writers. It is surprising what is out there.
Often when I hop hubs, I sadly find at least one that must be reported to the team at Hub Pages. The percentage of the time that Hub Pages is guarding is amazing.
I don't look for copied content so the percentage is even higher.
Kudos to Hub Pages staff for keeping us on target. Hub Hopping gives us a true picture of the great management team and practices that this writing site has created.
I find much more than ONE hub when hopping, and I don't usually report it unless I KNOW it's poor quality or spam.
It's a shame for HubPages, but I will say, in the same breath, there are many dedicated and talented writers out there, and I appreciate reading all of your work
Agreed. I did find a few gems in the midst of the garbage. Those few hubs are the reason why I do hubhop to begin with. Although I do flag each and every hub that is spun, pure garbage or stolen.
@Izzy - Yup. I don't check the known hubbers either. I know those guys feel the same way we do about this stuff!
I generally have to go through a few just to find one that doesn't need to be flagged--and I haven't even been checking for dup content. (yet)
Well I went hub hopping and got fed up hitting the flag button after a while.
One, on kitchen units, used the word "f*ck" instead of screw or whatever word it was supposed to be. It was unreadable!
Yet another was calling for the UK govt to hand out heroin to addicts like him instead of methadone. Not sure if that is against adsense TOS but probably is.
It seems that nearly everything was copied except those hubs from well-known hubbers.(which I'm assuming wasn't copied, I didn't actually check those, but hubbers don't get hubberscores in the 90s with stolen content).
Wow, I've never come across anything that blatant while hopping before.
As for the herione hub, I'm sure it probably is against google TOS since I know a blogger who lost her adsense account for blogging about her life as a cancer patient and it included the use of medical marijuana. I know she fought it, but I don't think they ever gave it back to her (which is ridiculous, IMO). Though I think the heroine hub is a completely different aspect of the whole drug issue. Haha
That sounds right, but I can tell you that you can achieve 3 yrs on HP, nearly 800 seemingly good hubs (usually copied from several sources vs just one), and an author score in the mid-80s...
Guess I'm the odd one out then cos I don't hub hop to look for gems. I hub hop purely and simply to look for garbage and flag it. I (we all) want to write on a quality site so we have to help the staff get rid of the trash!
No need Izzy. Just check in at chez Ewbie for some real gems.
Sorry, if that sounds like self promotion, it's meant just as a joke. Which I've now spoiled by explaining.
You have to be so careful these days.
Izzy, I'm with you. I mostly hub hop looking for garbage - I actually read and enjoy very few of them.
I guess I'll have to start looking for stolen material now as well, though.
Well, if you look at the link to Hub Hopping on your Statistics page, it says
"Help us out, Hop some Hubs".
So clearly, HubPages expects us to use the hopping feature for exactly that purpose!
Hmm... there is a free downloadable program called Paper Rater that will detect plagiarism. There are also free online tools that will search the web for written content to detect plagiarism.
The poorly written content is horrible. I have a feeling this is why eBay stopped giving accounts to hubbers (which makes me sad, because I would have loved to have had one)!
I've flagged a bunch of auto-translated, auto-spun into surreal poetry hubs, but I didn't realize the generation of them was this out of control.
Although it is scary, and an insult all of us who are putting effort into creating worthwhile content, some of the stuff I've seen is so bizarre, I can't help laughing at it.
"Mostly, you belike already bonk virtually Vizio, they are one of good manufacturers of LCD Video in the Unpartitioned States"
the Unpartitioned States
Anyway, I'm off to do some hub-hopping.
Here's one for ya:
The mistakeke fixedthe attention of citizensns just nowd collectionlection social networks abuzz with many users commenting on the mistakeke.
Just found a good one - can anyone translate?
'Daddy diaper bags ordinarily come in messenger bag types. That is due to the fact they are a lot more convenient to wear along. They are also created in various ways that might suit the style of daddies'
Being a Brit I didn't even know that 'daddy diaper bags' existed, but have done some research and yes you can buy diaper bags for daddies, the term daddy diaper bags attracts 1600 global monthly searches and apparently they make the perfect Valentine gift (OMG!) So, on your hubmarks, get set, go create a hub - don't think that any of us would have trouble outranking this one! LOL
Wow, I just hit "hop" and the very first article I came to was ripped off from another site. I didn't realize the problem was so widespread here.
It seems to me that a majority of the really short hubs are created for nothing more than having lots and lots of hubs that might generate income. I have seen some that are so short, they are just a couple paragraphs with pictures, and you can look at them for a few seconds and be done. I don't care for those.
I especially don't like a hub that has almost nothing to it, on a topic that I am interested in. I almost feel that I have wasted my time looking at it. There are also a few out there that seem like they are nothing more than someones attempt at telling a long joke.
But, for those of you who put out informative and interesting hubs, I say thanks. There are some really good ones out there.
I've never hubhopped before until now and look at the very first hub I "hopped"!
To head your Hotel Rimini magical and a woolgather get real, there are a show of ritual venues getable to match every ambit and enough and solon party planner to assure that your day is rightful!
I must be living right. Out of about 15 just hopped, no spun hubs and only 1 copied. Only a couple short ones, and they weren't the 50 word ones - just too short for me.
Well, I just hopped another 15. Only two were stolen (definitely stolen - sites like IMDB don't get their content from HubPages), two were spun, two were barely understandable (someone new to the language maybe?) and one was 46 words and a picture. Definitely better than what I have been seeing.
Dang! I wish I had heard of the name Flatbottom before I named my son Wolfgang!
Seriously, I had noticed the same thing while hopping and what got me was some of them had a higher hubscore than some of my legitimate, original, from my own mind hubs. What the heck?!
I didn't use the hopping button, but I did go through some new hubs (from the top tab, under "Hubs" and "latest"). I found three within the first two pages that were blatant adult material or spam. One had no words and was a series of pictures, including adult content and one picture was superimposed with a blog link. Ridiculous!
I just used the hub hopping tool and just about died laughing. The first hub I ran across was one titled: "Selling comb to balled headed man."
Oh, the poor men with balled heads! ROFL!
Shouldn't it be on the shoulders of the creators of HubPages to ensure all hubs being created aren't plagiarized content? It seems logical that Hubs should automatically be run through a plagiarism checker before publishing is approved... I'm not a programmer but it doesn't seem like this could be too terribly difficult to incorporate into the system.
I doubt any of my hubs have been copied yet, but how do you check to see if your material has been plagiarized? Do you just put a portion of your hub into google and see if other sites pop up with the copied content?
by Rob Welsh 9 years ago
How many more times are we expected to have to put up with Article Thieves who use HP solely as a place to easily Steal from and to enable those thieves to fill their own sites with our Original and Copyrighted articles/content/keywords that we published Here in good faith?How about HP getting more...
by Jessica 8 years ago
I found out this morning that this site had stolen at least 2 of my hubs. The more I looked, the more I noticed that it appears every single post on the site is a stolen hub, completely copied in most cases (including the authors' names and copyright notes, ironically). I see lots of names of...
by Katee Shew 7 years ago
How do you cope with stolen content?I am not talking about how to report it and take it down, I am asking about how you deal with the fact that your work has been stolen. How do you react? Do you continue to write? give yourself a break? Do you look on the bright side?
by Sally Gulbrandsen 6 years ago
I find this all so depressing. Can anyone tell me how long after filing a DMCA complaint does it take to resolve these issues - or is it as long as a piece of string?How does earth does one motivate oneself to write more hubs when this continues to happen.
by Teri Silver 9 years ago
I am having a major meltdown now, Because Hubpagges told me to, I signed up for Google's whatever it is about ads, now they've disabled it because they said I violated ... something about clicks. I don't have a clue what's going on.Nor do I understand how of this hubstuff works, when it comes to...
by Rob Welsh 9 years ago
These Thieves are back up again.. and once again monetized with that company that has a dollar each way on both the thieves and the Copyright owners... Google!It appears that much of the HubPages content has been shifted or merely re-published with all links, authors and previous publishing sources...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|