God created everything including the concept of sin, and he created people that he knew would sin before he created them so why did he deliberately create people who he knew would do things that he claimed are "sins" so he would have to send them all to hell for eternity?
Why does god hate us so much?
I must say, this question has some merit.
If he ever truely existed, then I believe he was a sadist. I think that Jesus bloke sounds like a much more understanding guy.
1- Who told you that God hates us?
2-Who told you that God hates sinners?
3- I'm not so sure, but if you were saying that all sinners would go to hell for eternity, then who told you that?
4-what is 'the concept of sin'?
As for the answer for the question "why did he deliberately create people who he knew would do things that he claimed are "sins" so he would have to send them all to hell for eternity?" I would answer you with the following, it's not about the sin, but about the ability to honestly regret your sins and go back to God, that's the point, because we all know that all humans are fallible, imperfect and so damned to commit sins no matter what. hope that answers your question.
G-d does not hate sinners. If the sinners repent and ask forgiveness from Him, G-d forgives them. Please
And when the "sin" is an inability to believe in an invisible friend that lives in the sky? What then?
One can always correct one's belief.
Obviously false. You believe in a god that does not exist - can you correct that belief? Not just pay lip service to not believing, but actually believe there is no god out there?
What was one's belief before one reached to one's present stance of "G-d does not exist"? Please
Many people have never felt the necessity to make up a god to give their life meaning or to provide a moral structure. For those it is just as it is now; a recognition that the likelihood of a god's existence is very small. No belief in a god, then.
Others have studied what we know of the world and of various god's, concluding the same thing. They have gone from a belief in one (or more) of the gods man has created to none at all.
And still others have decided that they want a god in their lives and chosen such a belief system.
Three possibilities, then - do you not find it so?
One did not answer my question.
Please don't mention about others, just answer the question in first person, it it is no secret. Please
"What was one's belief before one reached to one's present stance of "G-d does not exist"?"
I can't answer that personally as that is a belief that I do not hold. Only whose putting belief on a higher plane than knowledge claim to know whether there is a god or not - the modern gods are defined in such a manner as to make either answer unknowable - and a belief without evidence is something I try to stay away from.
As far as not answering questions, though, you seem to have conveniently skipped over some yourself. You never did answer the question asked of "You believe in a god that does not exist" - can you correct that belief?
Beliefs is a very open ended question , relates greatly to faith and confidence of a person or thing.
Even I am more spiritual sided than wilderness and with all my senses. I can not have faith or confidence in any one Religion or large Group.
No groups or Religion on earth has most people's faith and confidence.
Unfair question to ask a self made god like wilderness.Lo
G-d did not create them sinners. It is a wrong notion. He created everybody born innocent. If one commits sin purposely and intentionally, then one has to blame one's own self. Right? Please
Babies are innocent, yes. As they grow and brains develop things can change. Worse, their environment plays a huge part in what they will become. These things ARE from God, and not assignable to that infant.
So yes, God most certainly does play a huge part in whether a person sins or not. In addition to that, much "sin", as defined by religion, is not necessarily known or understand by the individual that infant becomes. Again, God has with held vital information from them and is thus to blame.
Does one mean that one cannot go against the environment? Please
Does one mean that one doesn't have been allowed freedom of choice? Please
A side from this thread, why don't more Muslims like you not come these hubpages for discussions. I feel almost totally alone defending the fact that Muslims are not terrorists. Sure the odd one Muslim may go insane because a million Muslim children have been killed.
Why do your follow Muslims be a doormatt to the largest terrorists nation in the world?
An extremist or a terrorist is simply not following the religion of Islam/Quran/Muhammad, he is doing politics in the name of a religion.
Does one mean that he should be forced not to do what he is doing? Please
What if the Creator of sinners isn't actually overseeing their every sin but has moved on to create other sinners elsewhere and just leaves sinners alone to find their own way back to non- sinning. Is that possible?
Yep. Perhaps he's moved on to judging all those sinners, who have judged sinners in his name. Who knows? I'm an atheist.
God doesn't hate sinners? where did you get that notion?
Yes he made it clear that He hates sin. Sin destroys everything it touches.
But His love is stronger than any hate,and he proved love by providing a sacrifice and subsitute for OUR sin.
His name is Jesus.
ie. Hate the sin ,love the sinner
Where did I get the notion? I explained that in my original post.
Well I just made 2 big batches of cookies - I told my sons NOT to touch them until after I get home from work.
I am sure one of them will. I dont want them too,but I know they all have the potential to scoff the lot and know that I will still love them- (next time ,I devise another plan)
No doubt they will reason in much the same way and have similiar excuses.
Sure I want to be able to trust them and maturity and wisdom will bring that ,just as understanding why sin hurts us will.
Except that sin and its ramifications have far more consquences than disobeying mum will,the principle is similar.
When a person becomes a Christian they decide that God knows better-even though they dont fully understand the complete reasoning behind the commandments.
Trust and obedience.
Like the children in Eglewiki's cookie analogy God gave man freedom of choice. He doesn't want us to sin, but when we do he made a way to clean up the mess. We all feel better when we get an altercation settled. When we do something that hurt someone then clean up the matter relationship is restored and everything is much better. Quit looking at God as some cosmic killjoy. He wants a relationship with each and everyone and thing he has created. He gave us the ability to do what we want. Eglewiki knows the kids won't learn without guidelines and loving discipline, but won't strike the kids dead if their freewill gets the better of them. There are consequences to actions. In Physics every action has a reaction.
What is a sin?when God hates all the same people you do...that seems to be a personal problem?
God does not hate sinners. Bad and good persons are same .
Fourth: honest scholars try to find out the good parts of religion and build them into a philosophy. For example, the law.
The worldwide law of, love, ethics and natural law is my Religion and God. A set of laws that is made possible plus has it's own karma if not followed.
Where other God laws are impossible to follow and are more Hippocratically broken by their own followers than anyone else.
Never have physically harmed anyone or in my life and eat meat less than the average person. Did kill some fish but ate them , yet no fish got harmed for long. I only tried to slow down the senseless killing and harm around the world by mainly the synthetics over ego rulers.
by Julianna 15 months ago
Why does God give children to those who abuse them? This has been a question that I have been trying to find an answer for. Discussing this through the years I honestly am looking for a true understanding of why? There are many in the world who would love to have children however they will never...
by Keith Schroeder 4 years ago
Why does God do bad things to good people if He really is just?I want honest answers only. No name calling or "my religion is better" stuff.
by Rad Man 6 years ago
Why does God need worship?
by Siny J 5 years ago
Why does God choose some and reject others?
by RKHenry 9 years ago
What is it about this word that gets everyones attention? If you want a successful forum post- just name God the founding father of it. Why is that? Why does god get all the attention? It seems that people can't get enough bickering, discussion, debating or conversing about...
by aahmed1988 6 years ago
You see lets make it very clear on this particular question, If the God you believe is in the skies, heavens, or somewhere only HE can see us. Lets say this statement was true. Lets also say, when we Pray for something we want and he makes it true. DID YOU PRAY TO BE BORN? DID YOU CHOOSE TO BE IN...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|