HubPages alerted me that this hub had been copied: http://hubpages.com/hub/The-Amazing-Lif … ine-McCoy, and so I wrote the editors of that website and asked for it to be removed. I got this back (see below). I am just appalled. I'm not good at confrontations and have no idea what to do. The 2010 was the original date, it was edited in 2013. The PHOTOGRAPHS in the article were public domain. I wrote the article.
ANY suggestions as to what to write back to this guy are appreciated.
I do not have a copyright certificate! I thought just to honestly write and publish something was enough!
What to do?
Thanks in advance for all words of wisdom ....
>>The source of your story is listed as "public domain" which was pointed out by my attorney. Can you please provide a copyright certificate showing that you are the author of this story? Also: You are specifically singling Panache Report.com out because our entry of this story does not even come up in Google when the twins' names are entered into the search engine. How did this specific story on my blog really come to your attention and according to my lawyer, numerous other sites have published this story, (not word for word but with enough similarities)-are you going after them as well? If not, why not? You mention that you published this article in 2010 yet my attorney says it was posted in Oct. 2013 according to Google.
Provide me with a copyright certificate listing you as the author and I will remove your version of this story and replace it with the Wikipedia story on the twins.
Or would you prefer to speak to my attorney about this matter?
Go for the confrontation. I bet you big bucks this guy or gal is all bluff. First off, an attourney would not make that kind of mistake. Second, they would tell him to shut up and let them deal with it for they know better than to tip off their arguing strategies like he just did.
Email back. Tell them remove it or you will file a complaint and report it to Google and they can speak to your attourney if they wish. Then, get to filing.
Go to the learning center to see where to file. This happens to us all. Don't be afraid. Don't give up. Never give in.
Forget about the site owner and the email. Send a DMCA to the host, GoDaddy.com at:
Put the words "Copyright Claim" on the subject line of your email.
[This is the email to send:]
Pursuant to 17 USC 512(c)(3)(A), this communication serves as a statement that:
I am the exclusive rights holder of articles on the http://brettwinn.hubpages.com subdomain and the owner and author of the following article, posted on www.HubPages.com:
http://hubpages.com/hub/The-Amazing-Lif … ine-McCoy.
These exclusive rights are being violated by material available upon a site you are hosting at the following URL:
My request to panachereport.com to remove my content has been unanswered.
This is my contact information:
[List a name – It's supposed to be your real, legal name
I have a good faith belief that use of the copyrighted materials described above as allegedly infringing is not authorized by me, the copyright owner, its agent, or the law. I swear, under penalty of perjury, that the information in the notification is accurate and that I am the copyright owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.
I hereby request that you remove or disable access to this material as it appears on your service in as expedient a fashion as possible.
I trust that you will discontinue hosting my plagiarized content on the panachereport.com website.
[Put the same name you used above at the end. This is 'signing' the notice and is required.]
Hehe, good advice. You got in a minute before me!
Writer Fox is right. Godaddy is the host. Contact them. They'll deal with it quickly. They will also keep a record. Any more infractions and the threat-happy thief may end up with no blog at all.
This. Always file the DMCA complaint with the hosting company. Don't even bother contacting the person who posted your content. They've already shown themselves to be unable to discern what is, and isn't, their work.
Yea, most thieves won't respond. I must have filed over 50 DMCAs in my time here. I gave up trying to contact the thieves. Maybe 1/4 respond. One was abusive, another was trying to get personal information out of me. Some took the page down. All are criminals though, so it's not worth the trouble of sending them an email, waiting a week for a 25% chance that they'll actually respond, then sending another email to the web host. Just use "whois" or "whoishostingthis" to find the host, and get them to deal with it directly. Saves time, effort, and frustration.
This website owner is 100% bluffing.
The mention of "October 2013" is because that was the last time you edited the hub. You, and Hubpages, know when it was first published. The fake "attorney" is just looking at the bottom of your hub and seeing the last edited date.
There is no attorney. It's a nasty threat from a narcissist. The talk about being "singled out" reveals the emotions behind the threat. In their mind, they own your story and you're wrongly persecuting them. It's a reality they've become comfortable with, and one you're trying to destroy.
There is no need to email back. I would even advise against it. This person will only get more nasty, and more threatening. Go straight to their web host. I assume this is panachereport (.com). According to whois and whoishostingthis, they are hosted by GoDaddy.
Send a DMCA complaint to the GoDaddy abuse team. Say you attempted to contact the author and they refused to take the page down. They should get back to you quickly.
How do you like that. He will remove your plagiarized story and replace it by plagiarizing Wikipedia.
You've been given great advice here about getting it removed, but don't be so quick to give up on your hub. This happened to me once. I emailed the HubTeam. They were so helpful and I did not have to delete my hub. Of course, I caught it before the filters, but still, they really are there to help. They are real people and just as nice as they can be when you are in the right. You are in the right!
Send them a fully complete DMCA take down notice. That is all that is required. If they reject it, send it to their webhost. Or if necessary to Adsense or Google or whoever else might be involved in the display of that material online without your consent until they get off their high horse and take it down.
He's bluffing. An attorney would know what the law was. You don't need a copyright notice. Just ignore this guy, find out who hosts his website and file a DMCA with the host.
By 'copyright notice', I meant the one we can enable on our hubs--when I last looked, the OP hadn't enabled it. It's not absolutely necessary, and probably doesn't usually do a lot to stop thieves, but it does at least clearly show the public when the hub was first published, which might have prevented this theft--because the thief is too stupid to realise that a 'last edited' date isn't the date of publication.
I would call their bluff and ask to speak with their attorney. I would also file the relevant DMCA complaint.
Please read my hub on "How to Copyright" your work and be protected.
This person doesn't have an attorney and is bluffing. All you have to "prove" is that you are the original writer of the piece. If another site published it and listed it as "public domain" then ask her where she took it from and tell her you'll be taking action against them to. If she had a lawyer, you'd be receiving something legal in nature. This sounds to me like someone who is good at theft of other people's work, don't let them intimidate you.
I would also send this person a copy of current copyright law. If you are indeed the one who published this originally, it is copyright protected automatically unless you specifically give away rights to the work.
Communicate by filing DMCA
http://hubpages.com/faq/#copiedhub Number 17
The letter to you states: >>The source of your story is listed as "public domain" which was pointed out by my attorney.
This is wild tell them to send you where it is listed as public domain. Also set a time for them to remove your work. That way all is clearly defined. Sorry to see so much theft from hubs.
Also have them forward you their list of the other places that have published your work so you can notice them also.
Yes, the owner of that website is bluffing and wasting their time, why I don't know. Looking at a Google of your article I see your article dated Oct. 3, 2013. Using Archive.com, I see that Panache Report's article did not show up until June 2014. It was not on their website in 2013.
Why have you deleted your Hub Brett Winn?
The first thing I would do, personally, is to get the web entry de-indexed from Google. Then I would file a DMCA. Nonetheless, the decision is yours.
That link worked a minute ago and now it doesn't. The link needs to be working to file the DMCA unless there is a cache copy online somewhere!
I would follow what Writer Fox (and Thomas) said. Lawyers work exactly like Rhonda says, so 100% this guy is bluffing (and full of 'you know' as well).
As far as I can see you unpublished the Hub (the link doesn’t work anymore). This is something I never would have done - it's like admitting you're wrong.
I would say the most simple way to prove that it's your property is the date you published it here on Hubpages. But since we have the possibility (and even encouraged) to re-edit Hubs once in a while, this wouldn't proof so much since the content has been edited. If you keep your content original (unedited) I would say you've all the proof you need.
I wouldn't go through the effort to register documents, but a stamp from a government authority or a notary on the printed original is as solid as rock.
They must be awfully rich because copyright attorneys are extremely expensive. You don't need a copyright certificate for anything. You only need to register copyright to go for punitive damages, but can still sue for actual damages without registering. This person (the one who stole the content) is full of crap.
I can only assume this person got to you if you removed your hub.
If you have found there really is an attorney involved (albeit a shonky one), all you have to do is show them a date stamped Word file, or a date stamped web file of any kind from your hub. Eg if you saved "Save Page As" your hub, it has a date on it in its properties that can be used as proof of copyright ownership. Therefore, always keep an original copy of your hub in some form or another.
You can send them a printscreen or something of the date stamping. But don't give them any original files at all or they'll pretend to be the original owner. Save it for a judge who will definitely determine in your favour.
To be honest, once they see you have a date stamped file, they'd be stupid to pursue it anyway, because they know they will lose and will pay a lot of money for nothing.
To get the original date of your published hub, Go to the hub and click on stats => Hub metrics. that is proof of the published date and I don't think you need all this Attorney things
Oh, gross. That email makes me feel sticky. They sound like a Scammer with a capital "S." I put your hub into wayback. Did you publish it in December 2010? This is what I got for that date: https://web.archive.org/web/20101218000 … tine-McCoy
Send this person that link if you dare. I agree with everyone else saying that you should report them via DCMA, GoDaddy, Google Adsense, whatever. Show no mercy. In fact, I probably wouldn't even bother sending this person the link. Just report report report. With a response like that I can almost guarantee they're doing this to other people. Disgusting.
No, they're wrong and BSing.
I would send them a letter telling them:
- please do check with your lawyer again on copyright laws. If the lawyer is at all qualified in that field he should be able to tell the person that you don't need a copyright certificate.
- include a link to copyright laws and information for them to educate themselves.
- ask them to point you to the source where the article was offered in the Public Domain, because the source infringed on your copyright. (If they tell you it came from hub pages, explain that free content isn't copyright free and is still under the control of the author).
- inform the author that if it's not down in 24 hours you'll be filing a DMCA, and explain what it is and what the result will be for him.
You have nothing to fear, you should stand up to this person.
I would also fill out a Google Scrapper report!
https://docs.google.com/a/google.com/fo … Y/viewform
Yes scrapper report is very useful. The head honchos at Google want people to report others who scrap. If they are busted they can get delisted off google forever!!!
You could enable the copyright notice, although the oldest comment is three years old, which proves the hub was published before 2013. You've received some great advice on this thread, and should have no trouble getting the copy unpublished if you follow it.
Love the hub, by the way. I just read it. Fascinating.
If this person really had an attorney, my hunch is that the attorney would want to handle communications in order to handle it correctly and bill it for the big bucks. They are screwing around with you -- that's my hunch anyway.
This I why I love Hubpages more, they inform you about broken links and Copyrights. If you truly didn't copy the culprits hub and instead it was the other way round, you need to stand your ground and fight for your right. You've got my back whatsoever.
I've actually only recently added the copyright notice to hubs that have been up years, and it automatically put the year they were originally published, so surely if you do that the 2010 notice will appear proving you wrote it before 2013. hope this helps a wee bit
And, this is why I feel strongly about signing or watermarking my own photos that I use online. People think its free to use unless you have some kind of notice on it. It has saved me some hassle.
They got the "Oct 2013" because that was the day it was last updated. So, apparently, their "lawyer" can't read, either. I agree - this is easily handled but the ball is in your court now. Stand up to them or file the complaint - but don't back down.
I have not read other replies, but yes, publication is sufficient and you do not have to have any kind of certificate to prove it. If I was you, I would tell the guy to have his attorney contact you or remove the story IF you are certain that you have not surrendered your rights to it. Before you say you never surrendered your rights, you should ensure that it has not been reposted by you onto a site like Digg, where the Terms of Service state that by posting a link to material, you confirm that you have the right to do so and that you are dedicating the material to the public domain. (Google is NOT the public domain!) If you have YOUR attorney contact the violator, you could sue for damages and force them to pay your reasonable attorney fees and court costs, I believe, so I would probably describe this in my letter to them, too.
WOW! I am just overcome by the generosity of all of your support, advice and detailed help! Thank you so much!!
I wrote him back and gave him 48 hours to remove the content. I just checked ... it is gone! Woo-hoo!
I had forgotten what a GREAT community this is ... you guys ROCK!
Indeed, I knew that person was full of it. Good for you forcing them to take it down. When we all fight the plagiarism of our hubs; I think it will eventually (hopefully) make HP less of a target because scammers will know, these Hubbers don't mess around! .
This was worth reading through all the responses to see the generosity and good advice from your fellow writers here. Kudos to all involved. (Except the scammer or should I say, alleged suspect scammer?)
This reminds me of Emilio Estevez saying "You mess with one duck, you mess with the whole flock"
by Justin Choo4 years ago
Since last week, my traffic (page views) has been decreasing. Hope not because of someone stealing my hubs as is happening so damned frequent recently. I will be at a lost if I am also a victim as I am not...
by Susan Ng Yu7 years ago
Help! I need some advice. Another one of my hubs has been copied verbatim with all the pictures, and the one who copied it indirectly refused to remove it.Three days ago I left a comment on his site politely asking him...
by Glenn Stok2 years ago
Do you have stolen hubs on sites hosted by WholeSale Internet, Inc.? I have found that they refuse to obey DMCA takedown notices and the copyright agent hides behind his secretary. I never can get passed the...
by Susan Ng Yu7 years ago
Hi. I recently used the "suggested email" template to send to copyright infringing sites and sent it to GoDaddy.com and they misunderstood it. Maybe it needs clarification? ______________This was how I used...
by James Bowden6 years ago
So far I have been faithful in writing exclusively for HP alone. But has any other hubbers out there heard of the writing site, Suite101.com? I was considering signing up at this site as well. However I do not believe...
by nightnight5 years ago
I was an active writer on helium.com.I want to move some articles from them to here and just off the web. I cant figure out how to delete the articles as their policy seems to be a little tight on deleting content....
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.