Why are so many hubs being posted that are low quality?
I have flagged about 10 or more today which are either copied, overly promotional, in another language, or have other obvious problems that are against TOS.
Doesn't the staff have a person who can devote some time to removing these before we even see them?
I realize there a lot of people who are struggling to make a few dollars.
I appreciate their efforts and am glad to encourage some who who are trying but still need a little help.
There should be some sort of automatic response to those posts which are OBVIOUSLY very short, very ungrammatical, or even copied.
Glad that you pointed this out.
I have noticed many poor quality hubs being posted, with grammatical errors, overly promotional, too short, and in many ways not according to the Hubpages standard rules. Surprisingly, they even pass the QAP and moved over to Discover.
Attention from the Hubpages is required regarding this issue.
An Indian YouTuber that has a 3+ million subscriber list posted about how to make money on HubPages recently. Since then there has been an influx of people. It may be a coincidence but I doubt that it is. Seems like he is just regurgitating other get-rich-quick schemes from other channels at a glance.
I wonder whether that video promoted "a day in my life" articles.
Paddygsound: How could anyone assume Hubpages is a "get-rich-quick scheme?" I guess we shouldn't believe everything on Youtube!
As best as I could discern, he was saying that you basically sign up and use some free-to-access articles and post them up as your own. PLR I think was the acronym for them. So at a glance it would seem to the average joe that it was a quick win. Of course scheme over the fact that content needs to be unique and not duplicated, and the QA process etc. etc.
Does the landing page still show profiles of writers making regular decent-sized payouts? If so, that might explain it.
It appears someone with >3 M subscribers posted this video for Indian audience on YT... https://youtu.be/ rpZ4hZRu0ro
I'm appalled to see the caption! Wondering what tips he's shared in the video which by the way has received 110K views within 4 days.
I took a look. What a load of misinformation. Explains why we are getting so many nonsensical diary posts too.
I've watched other videos in Hindi. They say how you can make money in Hubpages. Collect any article in Hindi, Bengoli or other languages Then translate it into English and paste it on hubpages! So they are promoting their videos by telling the viewers that hubpages is a money minting machine. Oh!
It seems unfair and unkind that HP offers false hope that this is a money-making venture for these folks. Also, it makes the forum a place that more serious writers, with good advice to share, simply avoid. I check in on the forum to learn, but it's mostly a wasteland.
I have noticed that, too and I am wondering what is happening to Hubpages.
Yes, Rochelle. I have noticed the same surge of new posts recently, many very short and displaying very poor English. It seems people are joining here in the hope of making quick money from their writing, but they will be sadly disappointed. I agree that new posts should be monitored and if they are obviously inferior should be stopped before they appear in our feeds.
It is NOT good for HubPages to have new people who might want to join in. If reasonably good writers see the poor quality of work that is displayed, they will not want to join in.
Again, I appreciate those who are really trying but some are just flinging undercooked spaghetti at the wall. (And if you don't understand that, you probably should not be trying to write for HubPages.)
Yeah, many of make typos in comments and forums. I'm not talking about perfection.
It is not yet finished. We will see more "I'd like to feedback" these coming days.
You're right, Rochelle.
There are so many more Hubs now! I've had to unfollow Religion and Philosophy because of this. Some stray far from the theme ... others say they are content writers but the spelling and grammar is so bad!
There are those who need some advice and I try to help, but others that just shouldn't be there. Some do ask me about making money true, but perhaps for others it's a therapeutic way of staying alive. Quien Sabes? (Who knows?) Thank you for pointing this out.
We've been here before. The best suggestion is to filter prospective writers with an English language proficiency test in order to unlock access to the platform. But HP doesn't seem to want to do this.
You are absolutely right, Rupert. Your suggestion has been offered on the forums before. I honestly have no idea why HP does not follow this suggestion. From a business standpoint, it is the logical thing to do.
Here! Here! Hubpages Staff are you listening?
Or, is this too much to hope for?
I agree that having some set of standards for new writers is a good idea, but that is the role the QAP process is supposed to play. Low-quality Hubs should never make it through QAP. If they are, that is a problem HP needs to address.
Is this a result of the new arrangement with non-monetized content living on HP? I was about to say low-quality content can't hurt HP because it will never see the light of day, but if all you have to do is mash your palm on the keyboard and hit publish to make the HP site, that very well may hurt the whole operation in the long term. Hope that's not what is happening.
I've seen quite a few & I am receiving emails asking for my help
I've had a couple too - wanting me to teach English. It's a crazy, desperate situation. They've been told that there is a pot of gold here by some unscrupulous operator.
Yes, the person that posted the video would be making a decent amount of coin from is subscribers, even 100k views on this one video would be paying well, then there are the many other videos that he has done on other ways to make money online.
Help is already there. One should how to grab it. Perhaps the way I take help from the article that read may not good for them.
I read the article, then I write down the new words and phrases in my paper note book. I do this everytime and I have a separate note book for vocabs. (Paper).
Then I make sentences from each words. In fact, I have used some of them in my articles.
I know my journey is not short cut. I have to keep on doing this for infinity.
Speaking of the pot of gold, are we still getting income from the amount of readership an article gets or is it only for ads now?
I have had to take some time away from HubPages recently. I wondered what had happened when I switched my notifications back on. I can tell from the poorly written titles of some articles that they are not going to be up to standard. I am hoping that the message will soon get across that this is not a get rich quick site and these articles will decrease in number.
I am sure they don't end up on Discover or above. Do they still influence the overall quality, impressions, CPM? Perhaps that is why Maven lowered HubPages.com without revenue — less work for staff and more angst for us.
That's so sad. I was thinking of starting back in hubpages with some new series of articles but thanks to your report, I need more motivation. Thanks Rochelle . I will now on, watch if there is any improvement where quality of some of these articles improve. Some years ago a friend had difficulty being approved here so despite his strong writing and content-skills when his article did not make it through I assumed perhaps hubpages' selection process was very stringent that means quality must be real good. I am shocked to see these way below--the-standard articles. I hope hubpages take some action so that hubpages can be referred to as a portal with absolutely quality-writers.
I'm not sure if this "sanjiv kumar" is the a**hole YouTuber you all are talking about (the YouTube link a few posts back doesn't work for me), but it seems likely. His video about HubPages was posted five days ago, which is just about the same time that the current wave of Indian gibberish started flooding the site.
Eff this guy. Everybody report this putz's channel for spreading false info.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCyLplL … qdv8MSmDJw
I did. Felt good!
That is him. He has definitely sold them all a line of horse you-know-what as you have said
I see you left a comment on his video about HubPages, paddygsound. You were a lot more polite than I would have been
I was tempted to leave a comment that said "This guy is full of sh*t," but decided not to since my real name is on my YouTube account. Haha
I'm leaving comments and replies and am being very direct. They need to know HP is not a get-rich-quick site. Thanks for the link.
I reported the video too. Ugh!
I'll ask Matt about the influx in low-quality content.
It is not just staying on this site. I've seen these "articles" moved to Letterpile and other niche sites as well. I know Letterpile is where poetry goes to die, but I have work there unrelated to poetry that does well, or at least it did.
Here is a great example. https://letterpile.com/poetry/The-Noble-Emotion
I asked LetterPile's editor about this and they said it does not meet our "harmful" definition. It was missing line breaks, so they fixed that.
I do not know what "harmful" definition means. I would not say it was only missing line breaks, but good to know what kind of quality is now being accepted.
This has always been the case on LetterPile. Our harmful definition changes depending on the site—basically what is and isn't allowed or what will affect our site's ranking.
I know what the editorial policy is for Letterpile. Creative work is still suppose to have proper grammar. The lines of poetry should still make sense and the poem should be a complete thought.
Do we no longer need photos and bios? Last time I tried to submit an article I still needed to include those items to have it on a niche site. Although I will admit the last time I wrote anything was over two years ago so things may have well changed.
You don't need to add photos to get on a Network Site. In fact, we prefer that authors refrain from adding stock images just for the sake of it. We encourage authors to add author bios, yes. But I don't see that implemented across every site. Depends on which site/editor.
Well, that is nice to know. I had no idea those policies had changed either, or differed from one niche site to another.
Policies have NOT changed (at least for a few years)! But they do differ—LetterPile is an special case. We can't hinder creativity by favoring perfect grammar. Though there are limits.
They absolutely have changed if bios are no longer a requirement. I have been fighting with staff including Robin before she left about editors creating bios for me in order to move them to niche sites. Letterpile being one of them. That was in mid 2019 (not that long ago).
They are required. Especially when going on more mainstream Network Sites. We still create bios for those who don't have them, but in this case of creative writing and an author that has no main HubPages bio, it's kind of difficult to make something up. Also, for newbies, it makes sense for them not to know the rule. But for those like you who have been here a long time, it's expected.
Otherwise, I guess sometimes articles slip through without them. It happens.
The easy fix for that is for editors to contact the author and explain they need a bio to move to the niche sites. However, for some reason your staff refuses to do that.
I understand it's not a "more main stream niche" and probably is more trouble than it's worth, but that is no excuse to not hold new members to the same standards/requirements. There is a reason this site does not do well, and it is not completely related to the topics not being frequently searched for.
I have watched some videos Hindi languages. I have reported one video.
Many newcomers are joining and their articles are not as per the expectation of HP platform and they are not featured also. They remain like that.
Wish I was a moderator so I could drop the ban hammer on them.
Look at all the time being wasted by us all to try and divert them.
There are a lot of videos about Hubpages on Youtube from India but I think Sanjiv Kumar is the source of those gibberish works on the forum. He has discussed "My Daily Life...." in his video. He also says that plagiarism is allowed at Hubpages.
I've not watched such videos. But I admit that I am also not so good in grammar and I misfire spellings.
I'm aware of my mistakes. At times, I feel that wrting is like playing violon. If you don't play it every day, the quality of the sound falls down so is the writing. This is my opinoin, perhaps I maybe wrong. Thank you
Gyanendra, at least you are aware and strive to do better. None of us is perfect so we do need to keep practising.
Jodah, I believe in what you said here. I also believe all the participants here. We all have to work together to weed off the garbages. Thank you.
HP, you seriously have to stop encouraging every writer you reject to ask us for help and feedback. Writers with small, fixable problems okay, but not the ones that are obviously beyond help.
Can’t you just create a standard ‘thanks but no thanks’ letter and send it to them?
The landing page for anyone who is not signed in still shows earnings figures for some writers (haven’t been updated in a long time though.)
Here’s a thought about identifying who is posting the videos on YouTube. I wonder if they’ve put a link there somewhere, including an HP code for them to make money from new members. That should help HP identify them. (Or maybe they’re just making money from YouTube visits, but might be worth looking.)
Is there a way to filter out Hubpages artices in the feed?
it would be nice to narrow down to just Discover or both Niche & Discover articles. I hate to miss out on those great ones
Not that I'm aware of, but you can use the feed settings to get some pretty specific categories that I do not think are available for HP articles which should bring up more Discover/niche site articles.
If you search for Discover or a category found on the niches (for example Dogs) some of the subcategories related to dogs on pethelpful/discover come up. That should help weed out some of the HP articles (on pets & animals) from those that would be on Discover and the niche sites. In some instances you have to be more specific. For example when searching dogs nothing about adoption comes up, but if you search for adoption both animal and human adoption subcategories come up.
It is not the best solution and might be time consuming if you want a wide range of content, but it might be worth it to unfollow the specific categories and try and follow more specific subcategories.
Yes, if you go to your atricle list ( upper left corner with three lines, and click on "Articles") you will see the filter list. A drop down menu will allow you to select your niche sites, discover and HubPages.
I am in agreement with you because I find even every second person is writing a poem and most of them are pretty substandard.
by Mary Craig 9 years ago
Wouldn't it be nice if some explanation about the hub came with the above mentioned notices. All you get is the general notice that you hub is overly promotional or substandard and it needs to be fixed. If it is re-submitted and is not fixed properly you could be banned from...
by DK 9 years ago
This forum is a place for you to post hubs that you think are clearly of low quality and need flagging. Committed hubbers should follow this forum and check these hubs posted for quality when they have the time. If a hub has been clearly copied (for example from a PDF file that the plagiarism...
by Don Bobbitt 6 years ago
Honestly, HP needs to step up and start filtering their input. I have been here for over 5 years and I have watched a lot of changes, but what I see as what must be the most damaging to HP (ergo we writers) with Google is the number of low quality Hubs being allowed in the gate. I hear a lot of...
by Steve Andrews 9 years ago
When it was first introduced I was annoyed by it but made an effort to tweak my hubs to get them out of Idle status. Now, a whole load have got zzs against them again and many of them are hubs that at one point were very successful and even now still have scores above 70 or higher.One of the hubs...
by Sabrina Yuquan Chen (陈玉泉) 11 years ago
There are two newly discovered hubbers who have only posted raw translations by using online translating tool, what they did was merely copy and paste the results without doing any further modifications. From the comments they replied, you can tell they don't really understand much English. Even...
by Shauna L Bowling 6 years ago
I recently had a hub un-featured for engagement, as the half-circle indicates. I think this is an unfair practice and should be eliminated entirely. Here's why I feel this way:Our hub traffic is often affected by the time of year, holidays, seasons, and current events to name a few. If left alone,...
Copyright © 2022 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|