Is the usage of "should" or "have to" in phrases like "he should go get some education" or "HP have to implement this feature" condescending?
Grammar aside, yes, it could be seen as being condescending. It seems to be a rather forceful choice of words. Though it would depend on the context.
A person could say it out of excitement. Or because they think it's a fantastic idea. Though I suspect that in the first example, telling a person that they "should go get some education" is the person trying to make a point that the other is uneducated. So it wouldn't matter if they said "it would be nice if you were to get some education" because they're most likely inferring that the person is dumb.
Though I did read today someone saying that they were "not in need of historical education" when it was obvious from their contribution to the discussion that it was more of a case of "I've never had an education in history".
It depends on the context, I think.
For example, "he should be going to school now", or "my child should be out of nappies by next year" is OK. Shouldn't cause problems.
Similarly, in the sense of a company, emphasis is fine, "Hubpages has to implement clickity-clackity features" is OK, I reckon.
Saying it to an adult is more iffy. If it's not personal, seems fine to me, "You should read XX book, you'd love it" is fine, as is, "you have to see YY film". But, "you shouldn't eat that cake" or similar would be a bit rude, I think.
Oh, thanks Amanda. Now I seem to be back where I started. Could it be Brits and Americans use them differently?
*scratching his head in utter confusion*
brits and americans use many aspects of "english" differently.
Theoretically its the same. It is a function of the circumstance really. Some situation never occur and some do in either land. It (the problem) applies only where the "crowd" where such an interaction occurs is of a Foreign base. If it was the same, who is to stop you being yourself? bah!
Misha, no. I'm American, and I was just about to second London Girl's remarks - and I'd say, exactly in the wording she used. I think, too, it's more important to ask what it is you're suggesting someone ought to (should) do. If it's "neutral" like "should be out of school at 2" that's one thing. The word, "should" is used in different ways. It can mean "as expected to be", or it can more mean (essentially) "in my opinion what ought to be done".
Even in the "you shouldn't eat that cake" example, it would depend on why you'd be saying someone shouldn't eat it. If you think they shouldn't have the calories or think they ought not to be eating junky food, that would be rude. If you're worried because you know a fly got on the cake, that's a different thing and not rude at all.
For the person who isn't sure if something will come across as rude or condescending it can sometimes help to simply add something like, "I think..." or "In my opinion (Hub pages should....)."
Misha, were you asking in terms of cultural standards of politeness or in terms of grammar?
If it's politeness, it's best to avoid telling others what they should do.
However, there are certain grammatical uses of "should" that have nothing to do with implying that you are telling someone what to do. Example: "Hubpages should be done with the repairs to the server in about two hours." That's an estimate, not an order.
The form of should that it is a future commanding form. I think shalt is the formal form used with thee and thy. And should is the common form.
I don't know if this helps or not.
It actually would be "HP has to implement this feature" Unless you say "Does HP have to implement this feature?"
And yes it is somewhat condescending.
I personally do consider such phrases condescending. For example (and this has happened more than once), any time someone presumes to tell me, "You should wear your dentures", I consider it a declaration of war. Amusing from a given perspective, but also very, very true. I've heard it said that far too many of us "should all over ourselves". (When stated aloud, a different "s-word" immediately comes to mind.)
Thanks Cole and Ghost.
I did suspect it was, but wanted to double check.
And btw, why HP "has"? Aren't they plural?
"It" is a site. Singular site.
And I agree, the above is condescending. Say it to me and I'll karate chop you.
True, but it just doesn't sound right. If that makes any sense?
Although it sounds plural, it is singular because it is one website or one group. Ok I just made that up, I really don't know why.
"Hubpages" is a company, and therefore singular.
Sometimes, we consider a group of people as one entity, and sometimes, we see them individually. It depends on you see the matter... I always use plural forms with hubpages bcz i see them as one...
absolutely. HP "has" is WRONG. it probably has to be "have" unless I'm terribly mistaken; in which case, I seek your pardon..
Our Mother tongue is not English .We are not born in England and US.
English is an adopted language or step mother language for me.
We are atleast able to speak, write or read English.
Can any Non-Indians read / write / speak atleast one of our 23 indian languages.
Misha, what a good idea to ask native speakers when you are in doubt! I am taking advantage of it right away and my question, or rather, two questions, are:
1. Does this ("should do something" phrase) sound condescending always? I always say "We should do it more often" when we manage to go to a swimming pool with my sister-in-law...and she answers, "We shouuuuld!". Am I offensive to her?
2. When a kid says "You should of done it", "You should of known" and the like, is it the slang variant of "You should have done it", or is it a normal, correct grammatical form? You know, language develops....
No, you are not being offensive. It does depend on the context as well as what you are suggesting or expecting and how.
We should all clap at Misha's forum. We'll have to tell him what a great idea this was.
Misha: It is all about the context. It can seem condescending even if you don't intend it to. "He should get some education" could mean you think he is dumb, or it could be genuine advice. The tone of what you are writing should (ha) determine the intent of the statement.
My vote for most condescending phrase: "You gotta understand...." If I hear that, I stop listening.
Aww, thank you guys, now I just have to process all this info, and I wonder if I ever get to a definite conclusion
Hey! We are the best minds around, and we can't give you a definitive answer. That's why it is a great question. It's an elastic word. If you are concerned it might be interpreted the wrong way, try re-wording your phrase. Or, add information around it so the intent is clear. Give it a big old cushion to lay on.
(Unless you are trying to use it in a negative way - in that case put pointy, sharp words around it)
Anybody dumb enough to tell me I should
Gets smacked upside the head with some would!
I don't think you should resort to violence
Suggestions are usually better received than commands, so when in doubt, perhaps it is better to use 'perhaps' rather than 'should'
also use the passive voice, putting the action on yourself instead of the person. instead of saying: "You really need to quit that" say "I wish you could stop that for a second" or even better "It would be great if you could hold off for a few minutes", or even phrase it as a question "Do you think you could hold off for a second?" or "If you don't mind..."
well then again, if your tone is condescending or impatient, or your facial expression is off, it won't matter what words you use, so never mind.
Perhaps you're right about that .
And then there is the highbrow alternative to should,
"must." Ss in,
"Oh Shiba, you really MUST see this movie. It's the bomb!"
"Misha, if you want to get a straight answer out of this crowd you must do some serious drugs ."
If you are TRYING to be condescending, replace should with need to. That will start a full-out war.
Mighty Mom, you should relax
I am thinking about it MM, there is so much advice on drugs over here.
Wyanjen, thanks, I take a note
Wyanjen -- Did you say what I thought you said?
MM you "should" relax?
Yes. I "should."
But I have learned that here in the Forums letting down one's guard (e.g., relaxing) is something one should never do! Right, Misha ???
Wyanjen -- no need to duck. I am reasonably tame unless provoked by a neocon. LOL.
Cosette -- you have great communication ideas. do you work with children?
OH! ok then. I'm a neo-hippie so we're all good.
You're not kidding about these forums though. They get brutal real quick.
just people who act like them.
no, although i have been told i would make a good teacher. thank you.
I have very poor grammar knowledge.
<URL snipped - no links in the Forums.
Technically, isn't everyone a native speaker unless you specify a certain country? Mutes and monks who have taken a vow of silence being the exceptions.
Technically, it's an English only site
Hi Eye, how are you?
Good, thanks. Did not see you round here for a while. Between Dems and Reps a sight of Anarchist is pleasing to an eye
I've been in and out, but I didn't write any hubs for a bit. One of the other spots I write for is an online magazine that does a lot of entertainment and night life coverage, so it tends to get busy during the summer. They pay me a fee per article, plus I get into every party in Vegas for free, so they get first priority.
Nice to see you here! Glad you've been busy and happy.
Are we saying mutes and monks SHOULD stay off the forums?
Does a vow of silence cover online writing?
And if a hubber was a mute, how would we know?
I read all the posts, did not see TK's. Was he being bad again?
by Linkya 5 years ago
Writing practices and advices for non-native speakers?I have started writing for nearly two months now. Four featured Hubs so far but contents quality are still mediocre and haven't get enough attention. Quite a long way to go. Every hubs I wrote, I spent lots of time searching for materials and...
by Susan Reid 6 years ago
What's the most rewarding part of teaching a language to non-native speakers?
by Lenzy 7 years ago
What do you think when someone says, "Does that make sense to you?"In Texas, this question seems to punctuate lectures on a regular basis. Three feelings tend to go through my mind when this question is asked. 1. Do you really care? 2. Do you think I'm an idiot? 3. If I really...
by Grace Marguerite Williams 5 years ago
What makes so many traditional and fundamentalist Christians so highly condemning and condescendingof atheist and agnostic people?
by Janet Giessl 6 years ago
Hi,I'm a real newbie here at HubPages. English is only my second language. Therefore, I would like to exchange information with other hubbers that have English as a second language. How are you doing here at HubPages? Isn't it hard to compete with the native speakers? I'm looking forward to your...
by Nemanja Boškov 7 years ago
I'm very curious to know what the natives think about this.I have been studying English for a long time, and I'll probably be a lifetime learner of the language as I am not a native speaker. On the other hand, I often think that even the native speakers will never stop learning new things about...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|