Have you ever ripped a book apart because the ending was bad?
I once read a book where the main character died, his wife was raped and died during childbirth, all of his fellow heroes died, and his kingdom was plunged into chaos. I tore the book in half and threw it against the wall. Have you ever had such a visceral response to a books ending?
Hahaha..not really..at the most all I have done is bang my head against the wall and hid the book where I wont have the misfortune to even glance upon...
That's....an odd ending. What is this book called and who is the author? I've never been that angry at an ending, but I've been sorely disappointed in several endings. Especially when it feels like the ending has no relevance to the rest of the book.
I understand your frustration because it is a human nature to hope for a happy ending but in real life it is not always like that. A good book is an escape and somehow a guide to a better future. It can also give you a valuable lesson.
Sometimes I stop reading a book if I do not like the content because I believe that what we think is what we are. Reading about destruction makes you destructive in your everyday live.
No but I walked out on the ending of the film "The Green Mile" From the shock of seeing such gentleness extinguished
No, but I threw one across the room in the middle of reading it- it was "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance." I absolutely loathed it. I also threw "Sula" across the room (although many of my friends who loved it were appalled and said I just didn't 'get' Morrison's symbolism)
I only made it to page three of James Joyce's "Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man," but I didn't throw that one since there were other teachers in the room, so I simply put it back on the table and acted like I had already read it.
I love both of your honest answers, and I thank you for your comments.
That's so funny- the same thing happened to me with a Danielle Steele book several years ago, and I have never picked up a Danielle Steele book again!
I think I did this when i was reading a particular book and the dialogue was absolutely ridiculous...it wasn't the ending, it was halfway through!
A book has to be EXTREMELY bad for me to rip the book and not even consider rereading or rebuying it.
Naaa .... I through the book into crap the moment I sense something stupid ahead ... so never came to such a situation
I have never done that. I just wanted to pass on a word of caution. It is much more expensive to do this to a Kindle version of the book. I do have to say though. I could have done bodily harm to Stephen King when I finally finished the Dark Tower series.
I have tried to get into that series on a few occasions, but , now, I will just wait for the movies to come out.
I just read today that Warner backed out of making the movies. An independant group is interested though. Read the books. Stephen King movies can be really bad.
I have not ripped a book apart, but I have given books away even before finishing them if they are too sad. I don't blame you though. I won't even continue reading a book if it is so sad and chaotic.
Can't say I've ever done that lol, but I've read a book that's considered a classic which I thought was mentally draining, depressing and just hard to get though. I would feel sick and tired after reading a few pages lol!
No, and only rarely thrown a book away. Once a friend of mine showed me his technique for making thick paperbacks more convenient to carry. He just tore them in half. I was pretty shocked, had never considered that before.
A book would have to be not just badly written, but morally awful before I would consider damaging it.
No but I have definitely thrown a bad book across the room before.I hate it when a book is good all the way through except for having a stupid ending that don't make any sense.
Though I've not ripped a book apart, I have definitely been affected emotionally by certain books and films. A bad example would be that I ran out of the Karate Kid just praying someone wanted to fight with me...of course I was 10 but I was ready!
book X emotion = (cover / pages) 2
Back in college, about 30 years ago, I was a big fan of Robert Ludlum. And the deep reason for that was that I could count on the ending. No matter how bad things got, the hero, outnumbered (and often an amateur) won against the big bad guys. Then I read one where he didn't. He survived to become an assassin, but the evil guys succeeded in their plot and headed on to rebuild the Nazi empire and take over the world.
I didn't tear the book apart. But I never read another Ludlum. And I felt deeply betrayed for 20 years.
I can't say I've thrown one across the room or ripped it in half, but I've read some real turkeys. I'd rather have a bad story line if the book is at least well written. The ones that get me are neither a good story or well written. You feel bad when it's over because some poor tree died so that book could be published. Just so it isn't a total waste I'll keep it in my back-pack to use instead of toilet paper when camping. May as well recycle and get some use from it.
No I haven't. That seems a bit childish. To do something like that shows a lack in self control.
I just finished "Unraveling' and it was good/but at one point I was hardly working/scuse me/working hard and got to a place so surprising and so not what I was expecting that I loudly said "No you didnt just say that!" and my co workers laughed at me!Needless to say I had to go back to work then,no longer able to disguise what Id been doing haha
as writers ourselves arent we striving to surprise/make people think/go outside their own comfort zones?
even if we make readers angry,arent we just wanting to make them use their intelligence and grow themselves as humans?
and isnt that what we want as readers ourseves?
I can honestly say I have never thrown a book across the room or ripped it apart. I have deleted books from my Kindle in the middle of reading them because they are so bad though.
I have never ripped a book apart. On the contrary, I have fixed some who were torn apart. I did this while staying in a country house away from the city.
I had plenty of time to read and when I saw those two books, I engaged in the task of putting all the pages together. When I finished, I read them.
Guess what, A book that allows you to see not all stories are happy, and not all lives are Hollywood perfect. Sounds to me like you showed a great deal of immaturity. Have you ever read the (Scarlet Letter)? it's a great read, however; it stares into the ugly of life.
Or...the book took such a strange turn that one may have not acted in the usual way; however, I was young at the time, but, who knows, I might do it again.
When I read the diary of Anne Frank, I felt truly pissed, because of the end, sad thing is it was true, I'm not even Jewish, I'm of German descent. Heart felt war, that one.
I haven't torn up a book but, like Steele Fields, I did throw one across the room. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. Right at the part where Aslan got killed. I did read it again years later and felt all stupid.
No. I have too much respect for books to ever destroy one. There is no excuse for throwing a temper tantrum just because you don't like a book's ending. (Would you throw your TV set against the wall and break it if you didn't like the way a show ended?) Even if I don't like a book, someone else might feel differently about it. If I buy a book and don't care for it--for whatever reason--I donate it to the public library.
We can agree to disagree on the no excuse comment, and I have never thrown my TV against the wall or thrown anything at my TV; however, if I can think of some situations where I might do so (watching TV in a Nazi Germany like situation might do it).
I've not done that... But I've hated the ending and wondered why the author couldn't have seen the end game as a glass half full.
No. I have had endings that left me sad, or frustrated but that kind of outburst goes against my reserved nature and I would be thoroughly embarrassed by it.
No, I have not............
I have cried at some readings.......
Often, when finishing the reading of a tale, I have felt the loss of a friend.
sometimes, I have wished that the saga could continue..............but, NO,
I have not EVER destroyed a book or its telling.
No, but I've ripped a bed sheet from anger because of a lie someone told me. Does that count? As for what you did to the book, I would never have reached the end-perhaps it was based on an unfortuante true story. I think you did the right thing.
No, never have done that before.
Because i don't read books (novels or any stories)
I only read textbooks like math, science, software engineering so I can't find a reason to rip it in half because I think that I will be needing it next time as my reference or I can use it as a reviewer.
(is my answer logical?)
As a writer, I couldn't see tearing up a book no matter how infuriated or disappointed I was. But I'm not the kind of person that acts out physically when I'm angry anyway so I think that probably goes hand in hand.
by Dean Traylor 4 years ago
What was the name of the worst book you've ever read?Some people point to Moon People. Others mention the numerous post-apocalyptic "Survivalist" tales. Either way, there are tons and tons bad books out there. What's your least favorite?
by DennisBarker 11 years ago
Spiritualist Medium is defined as somebody trained to receive messages from the dead and give evidence of survival of consciousness after physical death.If you have what was your experience/If you have not, what would make you consider having such a reading?
by Tessa Schlesinger 4 years ago
I am increasingly dropping an email to authors whose books either end on a hook or which, with a view to getting their readers to buy their next book, leave half the threads in the story unfinished. This does not make for a satisfactory ending.It seems that all the basics of a good book have now...
by David Livermore 8 years ago
Have you ever been ripped off on Kickstarter?I just got into the site and backed quite a few projects. Have you ever contributed money but not received the reward promised?
by LearnFromMe 9 years ago
Have you ever read a book that you just couldn't put down? What book and why?
by Mohan Kumar 7 years ago
Have you ever re-read a book that was your childhood favourite? What was the experience like?I recently re-read some of my child hood favourites and it was a strange experience - some stand the test of time while others left me disappointed!
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|