jump to last post 1-30 of 30 discussions (43 posts)

Would you date a homeless person if you found that you were sincerely attracted

  1. Rachelle Williams profile image90
    Rachelle Williamsposted 6 years ago

    Would you date a homeless person if you found that you were sincerely attracted to him/her?

    Not all homeless people look like what you might think...

    Imagine that you are in a social setting, and you meet a nice guy or girl that you find that you are physically attracted to him/her. 

    You see that person in several other social settings and  you start getting to know one another, and then you find that you are emotionally attracted to him/her. 

    Then when you meet up in a one on one situation, you find out that this person (although well dressed, well groomed, intelligent, and emotionally stable) lives in a homeless shelter...

    What would you do????


    1. Qmarpat profile image70
      Qmarpatposted 5 weeks agoin reply to this

      First things,first, I think I'd help him find a place somewhere. I'd bring him job lists help him sign-up for monster and some other sites. And once he had a job, I'd give him lists of apartments. If he got on his feet, at some point I guess we cold get to know each other. If he wasn't making an efforts himself, I don't think I would take it further. There are plenty of guys, that are working on themselves, who are available.

  2. NiaG profile image90
    NiaGposted 6 years ago

    Seriously, if he's just had a turn of bad luck and was out on the streets then I'd have no problem in dating him if we were "soul mates" or really seemed to hit it off on so many levels. I'd even let him live with me BUT he has got to eventually get a job to help pay the bills. And if he looked like that pic, he might not even have to work. KIDDING! :0) But if he is homeless just because he has a high IQ and doesn't think he should have to work or feel it's beneath him then no.

    1. profile image56
      XT10Kemunaiposted 17 months agoin reply to this

      I have the luck of a black cat.  I felt like I needed a fresh start in order to move forward in life, but I took a step backwards by underestimating the difficulty of moving to a new place.  I'm looking for jobs in Sacramento but no luck yet.

  3. Frank Atanacio profile image80
    Frank Atanacioposted 6 years ago

    I tried dating a homeless girl once, everytime we made love we kept falling out of the box.. you know how embarassing that is rolling onto the alley butt naked.. even the alley cats shook their heads in disgust...

    1. fpherj48 profile image75
      fpherj48posted 11 months agoin reply to this

      OMG  !!   Frank!!   ROFLMAO!!!  I just happen to see this very OLD comment.  I'm roaring!  You slay me.  HOW funny!!   LOL

  4. Alecia Murphy profile image78
    Alecia Murphyposted 6 years ago

    Maybe, I think each situation is unique to the person. Just like people fall in love with felons behind bars, I think you can date someone determined to not be defined by their present situation. I mean in this economy, it's a wonder not more of us aren't homeless.

  5. Lisa HW profile image72
    Lisa HWposted 6 years ago

    Although I'm more than aware that perfectly fine and mentally healthy people can find themselves homeless, I'd probably not want to start up a relationship with the person at the time.  Regardless of what's someone's problem/obstacle/challenge is, I generally think it's best of hold off on starting a new relationship before getting the biggest "complications to life" out of the way first.

    I certainly wouldn't rule out the idea of dating the person later.  Besides getting the "complication" of homelessness out of the way, that would also offer more time to get a better reading on whether this individual actually WAS as wonderful and well adjusted as he appeared to be

    When I left my marriage I was left by the court without a place to live.  The last thing I needed or wanted in my life was to date someone.  If I'd met someone I liked at that time I probably wouldn't have liked to do things like meet that person for coffee every once in awhile, but a person who has no place to live really needs to put his focus on doing whatever it takes to have a place to live and live a normal life before bringing new, major, elements into that life.  (Just my opinion and way of operating, of course.  Other people aren't quite the sticklers for cleaning up one mess before opening the door to another one, or else before bringing their mess into someone else's life, that I am.  LOL )

    In any case, if that wonderful homeless person I met didn't think the same way as I do about this particular situation, I wouldn't want to date him anyway; because I'd think he wasn't as good at minimizing life complications as I am (which would mean he wouldn't be right for me anyway).

  6. Darknlovely3436 profile image83
    Darknlovely3436posted 6 years ago

    I dated one and ended up married to him...  on the serious side of things
    sometimes in our life we have to say no.. to certain things. else in the long run
    it might haunts us.... homeless person need loving too, but, in the first place why are they homelesss.   , that a sign a red flag, and nope .. sorry

    1. profile image56
      Miss bee xposted 12 months agoin reply to this

      Its achually quite easy to become homeless this society. It isnt always a red flag

  7. Faceless39 profile image93
    Faceless39posted 6 years ago

    Anyone can end up homeless these days.  There are all types of situations that may be out of this person's immediate control.  If they are worth pursuing might take time for me.  Do they really have goals they're working toward?  Are they trying to dig themselves out of their current situation?  Is there actually going to be a future with them, or am I just dreaming?  It should take time to see if they're going to get out of it.

  8. Seek-n-Find profile image90
    Seek-n-Findposted 6 years ago

    I would start dating--whether with a homeless person or not--with friendship and test to see what the potential is.  People all have issues--they just look different.  The homeless person has one issue--and the guy who lives in his parents basement by choice due to laziness has another issue.  The rich man with a home that treats women as an object or a prize has another issue.  Friendship first will help determine if the person is right for you and if the person is mature enough (assuming you are mature and want to be in a mature relationship) to take wise steps.  When I used to date, I would only date someone that was marriage material because otherwise why get attached to somebody I know is not going to work out anyway?  The key is not one's home--but one's heart.  I'd take the homeless guy who made a few mistakes or some unfortunate circumstances that was humbled, learned from them, and determined to use the experience to grow over the rich man who is selfish, immature, and prideful.  But I'm married--so it's all theoretical for me anyway.  People in "love" tend to make up their own rules of engagement.

  9. THEHuG5 profile image61
    THEHuG5posted 6 years ago

    It honestly depends on the situation and WHY they are homeless. I mean I know stuff happens but...I probably wouldn't start actually dating that person until they got back on their feet. I'd be glad to be friends with them and help them get back to where they need to be as much as I could but their would be no romantic involvement until that happened.

  10. eye say profile image80
    eye sayposted 6 years ago

    as the situation described above, I would date the man ...

  11. Syrusv37 profile image88
    Syrusv37posted 6 years ago

    I would still go for it. A person is defined by the way they are and treat you, not by the home in which they live in. Everyone goes through hard times, no reason to abandon someone because of their hardships. If someone did that to me, I'd be a bit hurt.

    1. profile image56
      XT10Kemunaiposted 17 months agoin reply to this

      I'm in Sacramento, CA right now and I kinda took a step backwards.  I had a place in Pontiac, MI, but stupid me let it go because I felt like nothing else was going for me so I decided to get a fresh start.  I didn't expect to be set back this much.

  12. profile image0
    Daddy's Princessposted 6 years ago

    Knowing me I would probably take him home with me. I guess then he would not be homeless! LOL! But really it depends on the guy. It would not be a deal breaker to me as long as they had the potential to not be homeless. Now, if they were homeless because they just did not care about having a good life, that would be a different story. But then I would not likely be attracted to that type person anyway.

    1. profile image56
      XT10Kemunaiposted 17 months agoin reply to this

      Due to me not thinking I ended up homeless in Sacramento, CA.  I've been looking for jobs, but no luck yet.  It would be easier if I had a stable address.  It'd be nice to date a good female.  Not even for a place to stay, but simply for the love.

  13. capricornrising profile image60
    capricornrisingposted 6 years ago

    As some of us have already stated, this would depend enormously on the reasons the person in question is homeless. Are they unable to hold down a job because of a debilitating addiction? Or are they simply out of luck in this terrible economy? Two opposing extremes.

    1. profile image56
      Miss bee xposted 12 months agoin reply to this

      What if the person is ill and that's why they cant hold down a job

  14. Writingmystory profile image59
    Writingmystoryposted 6 years ago

    Yes I would. If I truly loved someone and he loved me then it wouldn't matter where he lived.

  15. engelfantasydream profile image59
    engelfantasydreamposted 6 years ago

    if he don't have a home then you can take him home hahaha joke3x...i think the guy needed a home that is why he is all around the social cirlcle or function..i mean homeless yet wow in funky cool clothes and all that..he must be using the charm to get something..i don't judge just stating my opinion towards this scenerio cos it is odd for a homeless person to be swinging all around so called social function,he should find work to earn money and rent an apartment, there is something wrong with him..attraction is just first impression..but it will not go on in the long run..it takes more than attraction that will make a relationship..it is not his being homeless,why he homeless and for the fact that he is homeless,,he get so busy with socializing than doing more productive stuff that will get him a home or to make him a better person!!!..now if you want to help him,and it is not where he lived..what kind of person he is..there is something wrong in this..don't be all gullible.."love is easy to feel" but hard to maintain!!!..

  16. Bella Nina profile image73
    Bella Ninaposted 6 years ago

    No.  I crave stability in the person I am with too much to date someone whose life is in a place of homelessness.  I was homeless as a child at times, and I don't want that to be a part of my life again.  I want to be with someone who can provide me with a sense of strength, purpose and security.

    1. gmwilliams profile image86
      gmwilliamsposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      Smart woman, people date people who have financial stability.  No romance WITHOUT finance!

  17. Hezmyjoy profile image61
    Hezmyjoyposted 6 years ago

    No...think about it. I thought it would be shallow to not want to live that sort of life or try to build him up to live differently but either way you look at it, if he loves you - he would do better for himself. If you love him, you would allow him to do better for himself.

    1. gmwilliams profile image86
      gmwilliamsposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      It is NOT shallow.  When people date, they should date SMART.  Smart people DON'T date DOWN, they date THE SAME or DATE UP!

  18. athena2011 profile image56
    athena2011posted 6 years ago

    For me it definitely would depend on the reason he was homeless. As mentioned before, this economy has made many people homeless.

    If he was just stagnant and not trying to better his circumstances then that would put me off. However, if he was doing everything he could to get back on his feet then I would have no problem being with him.

    It's not so much that he has to have a home, it's more about the desire to have a home that says a lot about the person.

    1. profile image56
      Miss bee xposted 12 months agoin reply to this

      What if the person is ill? Maybe the person doesnt have a disire if they are suffering from depression. I dont think that makes them bad though.

  19. perfectperception profile image59
    perfectperceptionposted 6 years ago

    My superficial self says no way but my caring side would want to help in some way depending on the situation.

  20. smzclark profile image61
    smzclarkposted 6 years ago

    it would all depend on what made them homeless in the first place. some people are forced into homelessness, others bring it on themselves. if it were forced and they had goals and ambition; definately!

    1. profile image56
      Miss bee xposted 12 months agoin reply to this

      I think its rare for someone to bring it on themselves. No one wants to be homeless. But I know there are some people like that.

  21. minikitten profile image90
    minikittenposted 5 years ago

    I suppose it depends why they are homeless, if they work, how long they have been homeless etc. A man made homeless through disaster (hurricane?) probably wouldn't be an issue, one made homeless through his own action probably would.  I may be open to dating a homeless man (theoretically) but definitely wouldn't be moving them in!

  22. Dazir lay profile image55
    Dazir layposted 4 years ago

    That is vary much true not all homeless people look filthy dirty and bad in fact you could maybe even know a person who is homeless but no realize it because they don't look dirty I think it's fine to fall in love with a homeless person I mean I did
    It's not that he's homeless cause he dose have a home and a family who supports him but where he lives ... He lives in a small little house almost underground it could almost be a basement and the house is FALLING APART every day but by bit he doesn't have a lot of food of GRATE CLOTHING he doesn't have sofas he has chairs and sleeps on the floor and his entry door if half broken so u can see everything in his house so it's not like he's homeless but more like broke he doesn't have a lot if money AT ALL but I don't know how he did it but I love him we met we talked and I knew that right there something had happened ... Do you believe in love at first sight? Well I do! Cause it happened to me and him and we have been together now for 4years I love him to bits and maybe JUST MAYBE we might even think about getting married and moving into a big nice house! smile <3

  23. arcangel777 profile image62
    arcangel777posted 2 years ago

    I don't want to be overly religious, but I find wisdom in the teachings / times and life of JC. I have to say I would open my heart [not let my brains fall out], and date a homeless women with compassion, wisdom , sensitivity, and all that could be described as love. JC was homless when he was born.
    I have dated women whom struggle with mental illness, and loneliness. Its to bad , but she couldn't believe in a relationship lasting. I would have stayed with her . I know what its like to see and even experience rejection, being made to feel you are a burden for some reason [I"m not]. My heart will remain open to that special one whether she walks into my life from off the street or from within a church or anything between. I know this is love, true love and love will find a way.

  24. PDXBuys profile image75
    PDXBuysposted 21 months ago

    I would date a homeless women - if she did not have some terrible disease and did hot have a severe mental illness and if she was not a criminal of some sort.  But that is because I am a man.  In general, men care about what a woman looks like.  Women care about how much money a man has.  That is the fundamental difference.  That is probably why you see more homeless men than homeless women on the street.

  25. rexy profile image68
    rexyposted 21 months ago

    l would rather want to know his background... because first of all l would not want any one that lies to hid anything as to why or how he became homeless.... l mean he might have had a bad relationship, or drugs related issues or wife beater.... But yea who wouldn't want some handsome ..... but l wouldn't take on someone that l would not know what he is really like.....

  26. cinders rauhlee profile image60
    cinders rauhleeposted 21 months ago

    If I truly liked them then I wouldn't mind. I mean I am attracted to you not your house.

    1. gmwilliams profile image86
      gmwilliamsposted 7 months agoin reply to this

      Unreal, do you have standards?   You really don't mind dating DOWN.  Smart people date the same or UP, not DOWN!

  27. profile image56
    Mersisposted 17 months ago

    As a man who has been homeless let me
    Just chime in

    Most of the people on here are assuming that people are or go homeless because they lost their job or just broke with someone

    But from my experience it comes from just not
    Making enough money
    And living out doors or on the road costs more money so you're in this perpetual hole

    And you would expect friends and family to help but in my experience the time it took me to save enough to get a place and live paycheck to paycheck immediately again

    They just end up using you and treating you like the plague or a burden

    I mean personally when my car broke down . Or all four tires went flat or whatever no one called to
    Ask If I was alright to pick me up anything

    But when they need something like they're gonna lose their house if these repairs aren't made  immediately

    And spend like four weekends driving 4 hours for a ridiculous amount of money like $20

    So you can't sleep outside and sleeping in a car is painful after three nights

    So you rent a room and pay someone 90% of their rent  and and honestly I've never rented a room from someone and felt comfortable

    Whether they want you to sleep with them

    Or come in and turn the lights out constantly on you

    Or people stealing


    You're still in this plague burden disposition

    And I don't call that having a home

    What it comes down to

    There are different levels of homelessness

    Personally when I pass people pan handling I'm disgusted

    They sit on the street and beg people for money
    And try to guilt trip me into giving them a dollar

    A lot of the time I didn't have a dollar to my name

    I feel
    Like screaming give me a f$&& dollar

    No matter how hungry I was

    And I've almost starved

    I've never stolen a dime a cookie

    And begged someone for a bite to eat ( excluding one time to an ex girlfriend , begged for a can of soup )

    1. Hezmyjoy profile image61
      Hezmyjoyposted 17 months agoin reply to this

      Interesting comment. I hear your frustration. I  came close and have been homeless. I was living with family and felt  I was a burden on them all of the time. It wasn't like that was my goal in life; nevertheless, you aren't answering the question.

  28. profile image56
    Miss bee xposted 12 months ago

    I am achually in this situation myself. It saddens me what a judgemental world we live in. I do understand that dating a homeless person isnt for everyone. That is fine. But its not nice when others judge others for thier choices . I am in a tempoary accommodation place due to the fact my family couldnt cope with a physical illness I have mixed with Cogntive issues. I was severly depressed at one point.  They couldnt deal with this either. I have met a lovley guy in the place. Never did I imagiene this happening but life is unpridictable. He is here due to having depression and possibly aspegers. This had caused him problems getting on in the world. He cant help being ill. Its sad that people are expected to not have love just because they dont are in a difficult situaion. My partner has worked very high up jobs in the past. He was really tried but does find life hard. As do I. We both have adhd and suspected aspegers so I guess in that way we are quite different. As in we dont go along with the social norms. Part of me disires normality and stablity and we have nearly broken up just over the fact I worry about what people will think but I do love him. He is very caring, loving, completly accepts me for who I am. Yes the situaion is ideal and I never saw this happening to me but life works in strange ways. So obvisily my answer is yes and I am currently in that situaion. I think people should remember its achually quite easy to become homeless in this society. And no one really wants or asks to be homeless. Apart from a rare few.

  29. realtalk247 profile image70
    realtalk247posted 6 months ago

    No. Homelessness is an unfortunate situation and while I am compassionate rather than dating, I would think that person needs to focus on rebuilding their life.  Can't trust people in extremely bad situations and take them into my life/world.  In my opinion people without resources will tell you anything for food and shelter therefore I can't believe in one's sincerity because of their circumstances.

    Is that person homeless due to unfortunate circumstances?
    Are they homeless because they smoke crack and rob? (then I date them and my stuff comes up missing?)
    Are they homeless because they just got out a few months ago for murder?

    I've lived life to long to believe in the lady and the tramp situation. Never seen that play out well 9/10.

  30. profile image60
    faydraposted 6 months ago

    I don't date anyone who is homeless.  They have nothing to offer me and are a handicap.  If s/he lives in a homeless shelter and is "well dressed" and "emotionally stable" I would question them on if they are writing their thesis or are they working with the homeless or something along that line.  Listen, a bum on the side of the road holding a brown bag to his mouth is: a drunk.  A person with needle marks is: yes, a drug addict. 

    If you want to help raise the status of a homeless person, go ahead and take them home.  They have a lot of baggage - do you?