so how do you feel about people who write hubs accept the comments and don't reply to them? I find myself doing that about 80% of the time because I run out of things to reply. also because I am a bit lazy. also because I wonder if you comment how you would know whether I reply or not, unless you go back looking for a reply. and if you go back looking and don't see one do you hate the hubber? just wonderin
If they are not my friends, after the third time without commenting back, I don't read their hubs anymore.
I am a very social person, yes I do get frustrated when I see no reply. You don't even know whether the hubber has read your comment or not.
To me, you go to the effort to read their hub and leave something encouraging to say, just one word like 'thankyou' in reply would be enough lol.
I always answer my comments I think if someone has gone to the trouble to come here I am going to pull my finger out and go to the trouble of thanking them.
Well, you do know if the Hubber has moderation switched on, because they'll have to see it to moderate it.
That's the difference between HubPages as a social site and HubPages as a writing site. Those who treat HP as a social network, will leave comments for the purpose of encouragement and interaction. Not every Hubber is here for that purpose.
Do you mean you keep a list of all the Hubs you've commented on, and go back to check? Because as you know, there's no easy way to keep track, and some Hubbers don't check their comments every day.
As I've said before, saying "thank you" to someone on your own Hub is like saying "thank you" to someone after they've left the room and closed the door. Don't see the point, never will.
yes! now, see, this is exactly what I'm talking about - once I'm through reading a hub (unless its super good info and I bookmark it) I don't go back to see whether the hubber responded, and from the looks of my hub commenters, they mostly do the same so it would be pointless for me to always respond. If they are asking a question or get me started thinking or offer a suggestion, (and really the best place for that would be in an email to me) then sometimes I will respond. But I am not having the time to read all the hubs I want and write all I want so I'm not going back to respond to the hubbers response. I check in in the forums almost every day (the hubtribe thread) and so people can communicate with me there. I just don't think hubbing is like blogging where you can start up a friendship with someone after reading their blog, right there in their comments - mainly because when I blog on blogger it is one big thing all connected, not a bunch of separate articles!
now, have I bored you to death with this! (no need to respond!)
Exactly, mega. On a blog, people can sign up to see whether someone responds. The HubPages system is not set up that way.
In my book, if you want to thank someone for commenting on your Hub, a much more effective thing is to go and comment on one of their Hubs.
and then, if I don't like their hub much, I could say, like "so glad you are a hubber" ? or "thanks for this info" (meaning thanks for revealing yourself as a lousy writer who I will never look up again) ? like that? jus kidding
I like that Marisa...comment on their hub if they comment on yours. I'll definietly start doing that as my 'thank you' when ppl write on my hub.
No only sometimes I go back if I have asked a question to the hubber or left something open. I don't get angry at the hubber if they haven't replied but I do feel a little disappointment.
there is a list of hubs you commented on from your account page. I have gone back to check some comments I've made to see if the hubber responded. some like to go back, others dont...
You do it right, Blondepoet, and most hubbers do it like you do it.
That's not true, Earthlover. Blondepoet's attitude is not necessarily the majority view. It's just that the most socially active Hubbers are also the most vocal in the forums, and the ones you run across most often.
There's a large contingent of Hubbers who are busy making money here, who aren't so socially active and who don't regard comments in the same light at all.
Your large contingent ain't the majority, Marisa Wright.
give us the statistics, then, based on a scientific survey that can be corroborated! but then you sound like one of those hubbers who, when others disagree, you try to bully them into submission! which, of course, is just despicable etiquette, to say the least!
Marisa Wright is the one telling us what the 'large contingent' does or doesn't do. Ask her for the statistics. Pretty sure she knows.
I was responding to you, not Marisa. You were responding (in a demeaning sounding way) to Marisa when you said the "large contingent ain't the majority" I was asking YOU to back up your comment, not Marisa. I agree with the things Marisa has said.
I'm not aware of having bullied anyone - please report the post to Hubpages admin if I have.
What I am doing is standing up for the opposing view. If you go back through this thread, you will find several people who object to being told what is "polite".
HubPages is used in different ways by different people. If you want to use HubPages as a social networking site, then it's quite legitimate to follow everyone who follows you, read and comment on all their Hubs, reply to every comment, etc.
If you're trying to make a living online, though, you have to be more focussed. Socializing to that extent consumes a lot of time which you simply can't afford. You should respect the right of those people who want to get on with their work, and not call them rude for doing so.
It's like being in an office - you may not have much to do and be happy to hang around the water cooler chatting to your friends, but that doesn't mean it's right to accuse someone who's working hard of being "impolite" when they ignore you and keep working.
You've written 118 hubs in 3 years. That's not many. Not enough to keep you soooo busy that you haven't got time to reply to a comment.
Writing 118 hubs in 3 years isn't like working (in an office).
Anyway, I'be seen you on the forums at least as much as any of those you're accusing of 'social networking.'
Someone was on the high school debate team...
Just see through the established, mature hubber with a hubber score of 100, and you'll notice the drivel.
I agree with you - I was responding to earthlover when I said he sounds like those hubbers who bully others when they don't agree. I wasn't calling you a bully, at all, no way, Marisa! so let's not get this discussion all convoluted ok?
You edited your comment before I finished replying.
And what difference does being busy making money here have to do with anything? Bondepoet's doing that as well, but she's still got time to reply to comments, and look for replies.
I try to reply to comments whenever I have something to say. However, most of my writing is hard for me to talk about so I don't really like to say anything after I publish it. To say "Thanks for the comment" to every single person seems pointless to me and, a lot of times, that's really all there is FOR me to say.
Hi there mega! I know what you mean - someone needs to write a definitive HP etiquette guide. I try to respond to all my comments, but sometimes I just don't get around to it.
I know I enjoy it when authors of hubs for whom I've written comments write back to me, but I don't obsessively go back and check for it either.
So...in an ideal state of affairs, I would answer all my comments and I strive to, just because I like to be answered...but it's not always possible, and I assume everyone understands that.
maybe I'll just have to keep a list of the people who say they go back and check for a response to their comment! then when I see a comment from you or Tantrum, for example, I would respond because you want to see my thankyou! is that what I should do?
Your hubtivity on your profile page has a list of things you have recently posted-- sometimes I re-check those to see if someone has made a further comment.
People can do what they like-- I try to respond to commenters, but am not offended if I am not acknowledged. It's not personal.
i always comment back. sometimes though i miss some...i approve them and then get distracted with the phone or something and forget. i feel bad when i stumble upon a hub where i missed commenting someone. for me it's not a question of 'hubpages etiquette' it's a matter of common courtesy and good manners. someone took the time to read my hub and leave a comment - that deserves a response.
Its ok, we all know you're a girl but, the part we don't get is how you ran out of something to say!
I never expect a reply to a comment. If you want a reply you might consider sending an email to the author.
I sometimes go back and reply sometimes don't...depends on what kind of mood I'm in
I reply. Every once in a while I miss one somehow, but generally I always try to take the time to at least say thanks for reading and commenting.
I think it is good manners to comment back, even if I have nothing to add. In that case I thank the commenter for commenting, because they have taken the time to comment.
I don't often go back to check if they have replied, if I didn't ask a question, but never say never! I've been back on a lot of hubs, basically because they were good hubs and worth going back to, or they were educational hubs that taught me something.
To be honest, I feel a bit disappointed if the author didn't reply to me, even if I would never have known if I hadn't had a reason to go back. It's manners nothing more.
There have a couple of comments on my hubs that I know I haven't replied to, simply because I was really busy or in a rush when I saw them and I later forgot! My apologies to the posters, because your comments are important to me
I reply if the comment is one which leads to further commentary, such as a question or a statement that triggers me to say something further.
But as Marisa pointed out, most comments are made by someone who was just passing by, who didn't hardly say anything and who will never be back again, so I'm not one who replies to every single one.
Sometimes its hard to reply, I try to, but sometimes I just don't know what to say.
I don't feel obligated to reply to every single comment. I would like to, but I'm a busy student and I'm here to make money. Sometimes, commenting back can further enhance your hub, if not, then I just hit approve.
I try and reply to every comment, even though its sometimes difficult not to say the same thing over and over again.
i try to read and comment on one of their hubs in lue of the comment reply. i don't like it that by me replying to a comment it counts as a comment . i don't want half of my comments to be my own so to speak. To anyone out there tho that has left me a comment on a hub of mine . I want to tell you it means the world to me that you even bothered to check my junk out. maybe i should start replying . i feel like a ass now.
but i do read and comment on a hub of yours instead . tantrum know this. i appreciate you . ill tighten up i sware it.
I try to reply to all of the comments-just as when I post a response on the recommend another hubers hub thread,I post a comment on that hub I am recommending-if I read a hub/ I try to leave comments so the huber knows that their hub has been read and appreciated (even if I dont like the hub, I will leave some sort of comment, (because it shows support for their work as a writer)-and when I decide I will follow someone I leave fan mail.
I do it because I appreciate the time people take to read and comment on what I write, and responding lets me tell them 'I read your comment-and I appreciate you coming by and taking the time to read my hub, when you could have chosen to read someone elses'.
I don't get mad or hurt when I leave a comment and get no response to my comment, especially if it was a "Nice Hub" or "Good Job" type of comment. But if I took the time to read-and reply to a question asked within a hub-or really put some time in what I comment-I think it speaks better about the writer if they acknowledge their readers with a quick response-it shows appreciation for them.
But that is just me-Everyone does things for different reasons
(what does bother me, is when someone leaves the same fan mail for each person that they follow-makes me think they didnt even bother to read a thing I wrote and if I havent conversed with them in the forums, I feel as if they are becoming a fan to earn a fan/ just to increase traffic to their hubs and increase their writers score- I appreciate the fan-but it would be nice if you could read at least one hub)
oh, and also, it occurs to me that hub admin set up the comment tab in the my account section so hubbers can accept or reject without having to go back in and out of the hubs - much more convenient. You know we've seen the comment then, because its been accepted. right? and someone said that whenever the hubber clicks on their own hub it counts as a "view" - now I haven't been able to see the numbers change after I've gone back to respond to comments - so what's up with that? I thought it was not good to increase your hub views by going back to your own hubs too many times. don't they ask us not to?
going to go check now and see if there is a Hubbing for Dummies hub . . .
there are two hubs Hubpages for Dummies A to Z part 1 and part 2! so may haps I'll find answers to all my stupid questions.
I just want to say that if you get a comment from me on your hub, don't expect me to come back and read your response! so no need to respond to my comments because I won't see it!
As I have a few hubpage accounts I may forget to go back and reply for a few days as this waynet one is my main account, but I always try and reply back to a decent comment since someone has taken the time to type a comment in, then why not!
I reply quite faithfully, though not always the same day the comment is made, just because I think it's polite. I doubt very many people go back and read the reply.
However, reply or not, let's not sweat the little stuff. I'm sure we are all well-intentioned people, whether we reply to a comment or not.
can't help it - sweating the small stuff is pretty much what I do! all day long and even in my dreams - got any advice for me, other than "well, don't do that?" because I could use some constructive advice about how to just quit doing something, or looking so damn closely, or obsessing over a minor question, or doing like, well what I'm doing right now even! lordy
That's what I was trying to get across. I think you did a better job! Couldn't have said it better.
If it is a comment worth replying to, then yes. For months I thought I must comment on everything, but of late I've backed off. No point in saying "thanks for the comment" I appreciate the comments very much.
freelanceworld published http://hubpages.com/hub/hubpages-for-dummies-A-to-Z but part one at least, doesn't appear to have addressed etiquette questions. So maybe someone who know will publish hp ETIQUETTE for dummies - oh, didn't search etiquette - brb . . .
I almost got sidetracked by dfelker's Good Houseguest Etiquette - Do's and Don'ts which sounds like something many should read - ha!
Of course we could end each hub with " To those of you who take the time to comment: I reallly REALLLY appreciate you and your comments, you are so kind."
scanning through the thread I see a direct correlation between number of hubs published, time on the site and the answer to this question.
I always answer direct questions and get engaged in informed discussions.
'Thanks", "Nice Hub" "Good Job" WITHOUT any sense of engagement is not only not responded to, its most often deleted.
When you say, "I answer every comment", i wonder...how many comments do you have to field on a daily basis, and isnt it disappointing to pour your thoughts and effort into an article..get a notification of a new email (if you do that) open up your hub to read a comment and see.
...what are you supposed to say back? ..hmm.. nice comment?
The above approach is how I deal with about 50% of the comments my Hubs receive.
Hmmmm...that's interesting. I might start doing the same...when someone comments like that on a hub it usually means they didn't even read it!
I hate those comments that are made that have NOTHING to even do with the hub.....that's my PET PEEVE!!
Yeah, that hasn't gone unnoticed.
But those comments aren't just 'Thanks", "Nice Hub" "Good Job", are they?
We both know that, don't we?
Why do YOU delete at least 50% of comments?
I try to reply to all of my comments, don't always manage it, but I feel that if someone has felt it worth the time to comment on my work, the least I could do is respond
Oli, no one ever addresses my point on this - if you reply to the person on your own Hub, how do they know you've responded? If you want to thank them, wouldn't reciprocating the comment be a fairer exchange?
For instance, go to their Hub, make a comment and add "thanks for your comment on my Hub"
That's not the right way to do it, Marisa.
Leaving a comment on someone's hub just cause they left one on yours is the same as following someone just cause they followed you. Do you do that?
And you need to say more than just 'thanks for commenting on my hub'. If you know about PR, and I saw you mention that somewhere, then you must know how to reply to a comment. It's elementary.
You're just making excuses for slobby, careless behavior.
So,, let me get this right... you're saying don't comment on anyone's hub unless they are truly interesting to you and you've read them thoroughly? I completely agree!
Yeah! That can be the only right way to do it.
And always go back to hubs you've commented on to see if there's a reply.
Who doesn't? That's why it's good to reply.
I have no idea whether people have replied to my comment - unless I asked them a question there (which I don't do anymore) why would I go back and give their hub another view click to see if they replied? the appropriate places for questions and answers and communicating back and forth is in the questions section or through the emails or even in the forums. and of course, now I know that it all does not matter in the great scheme of things.
Just like to add, Marisa: You don't comment on hubs by everyone who comments on yours ... what does this mean?
Here are some rules:
COMMENT when you want to, or when you feel like it, when you are inspired, when you think it will help or encourage someone, or when and if you have time
REPLY to comments when you want to, or when you feel like it, when you are inspired, when you think it will help or encourage someone, or when you have time.
DON'T be offended when people don't comment or don't respond to your comments. They may not want to, or feel like it, or think it will be inspiring or helpful or encouraging. Or they may not have the time.
Most important: I don't make the rules.
ha ha ha Rochelle! You don't make the rules, but your rules are good to write by!
Personally, I comment on every comment, and I try to comment on every hub I read. I believe that if a reader has taken the time to read my article and write a comment, the least I can do is to acknowledge this fact with a comment back.
I've been here 2 years now and have not been the best at replying to comments - but recently have made a deliberate effort to respond. I don't however feel that it's "etiquette" to respond, that it makes a hubber better or worse or insensitive in anyway.I just think it's an individual thing, and I personally don't get upset if my comments don't get responded to. Since I do write some pretty controversial stuff though I do find some very long comments on some of my hubs - that other people come back and volley back and forth about. I like that type of interaction and realized how important the interaction is, hence I am ramping up my own responses. I think the interaction IS important and is helpful to us as writers to acknowledge our readers, even if with a simple YW or TY for coming by. I will respond to several comments at once too.
Just my 2 cents on it!
I try to reply to comments, although there are a few I have missed and I don't mind if people don't reply to my comments.
Since most Hubbers do reply to comments left on their Hubs, most Hubbers also go back to comments they've left to see if there is a reply.
I reply to all comments, and go back to see if there's a reply to a comment I've left. I know I'm not the only one who does this, especially because many comments are a reply to a reply to a comment left -- get my drift.
If somebody chooses never to reply to comments, okay.
But if somebody only replies to some comments, well it does look a bit like snubbing other comments, or the Hubber who has made the comment.
Anyway, I think the reason most Hubbers reply to comments, is because most Hubbers understand good form. That's one of things that makes being here so nice.
I abandoned this thread a while back when I saw that there was a major conspiracy afoot to confuse, bewilder and bother me about this commenting thing. So now, I can only be like my mentor Rochelle and do what I want to - pretty much. If anyone doesn't like what I do, they can email me and then I can report them as a stalker!
or, as I should have said in my politest hubber manner:
Thank you all for showing up here for this debate on the serious and important topic commenting dos and don'ts. I hope we continue to meet like this for meaningful discussion of other etiquette issues such as:
when is a$$ a good word to use?
is there a time or thread where we should not discuss sex or flirt with the other hubbers?
if you do flirt with another hubber who is believed to be of your own sex, does that make you a homo-hubber? not that there is anything wrong with that!
and if you out yourself as a homo-hubber in that manner (not that there is anything wrong with that!) does it mean that certain other homo-hubber-phobic hubbers will come and torment you? is that ok if they do?
if you write a horrible hub because you are having an off day, and you don't realize it until a couple days later, is it too late to apologize, publicly?
implying that someone is something or other, is that ok? would it be better to just directly call them out for it? how do I word it?
and so on . . .and on. . . and on!
Oooo can I stalk you mega? Purty please?
I reply when I can, it doesn't really take long, but sometimes i am a little rushed!
by Lesleysherwood 8 years ago
Do you find that leaving comments and replying to them increases your stats, or does it take you away (time wise) from writing hubs?
by earnestshub 11 years ago
When I get a comment on one of my hubs I usually reply, at least with a thanks if I can. I notice some do and others do not reply to comments.I am wondering if there is any reason for not replying apart from being too busy to do so? Is it bad for bandwidth? does it score against your page rank,...
by ryankett 11 years ago
When I started on hubpages I used to reply to every comment, and I still appreciate them as much as I used to...But is there a point when it becomes unneccessary to reply to comments? I think that its great when people reply to every one of their commenters, I really do, people like Sufidreamer...
by Carolee Samuda 6 years ago
Why is it that some writers do not respond to individual comments on their hubs?I noticed this with some writers who have been on HP for two years or more. They will choose to respond directly to some comments and ignore the others. Doesn't it make you feel like not commenting on these writers...
by Julie-Ann Amos 12 years ago
In another thread trish1048 made a comment about comments - I found it a bit of a shock to be honest. I'd really appreciate other viewpoints please? What she said was: "What I greatly appreciate are the hubbers who always respond to their comments. Nothing frustrates me...
by Dennis L. Page 8 years ago
Why do people write personal fan mail notes, but yet haven't commented on an article?Am I the only one who sits in utter amazement at people who send personal fan mail notes telling you how wonderful, inspiring, creative and informative your writing is, only to find out they have NEVER even written...
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|